SCAR vs ACR - Final Thoughts

Published on August 6, 2012
Duration: 16:15

This review compares the FNH SCAR 16S and Bushmaster ACR after extensive testing. While the SCAR is lightweight with good recoil, its reciprocating charging handle and flimsy stock are noted drawbacks. The ACR, though heavier, offers a non-reciprocating handle, a sturdier stock, and a quick-change barrel, making it the reviewer's personal preference.

Quick Summary

The Bushmaster ACR is preferred over the FNH SCAR 16S due to its non-reciprocating charging handle and sturdier stock, despite being heavier. The SCAR's reciprocating handle and flimsy stock are significant drawbacks.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: SCAR vs ACR Comparison
  2. 01:23SCAR 16S Overview & Criticisms
  3. 03:15SCAR 16S Disadvantages Explained
  4. 05:13SCAR 16S Advantages Highlighted
  5. 06:28Bushmaster ACR Advantages Detailed
  6. 09:14Bushmaster ACR Disadvantages Noted
  7. 11:24Final Verdict: ACR Preferred Over SCAR

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main advantages of the FNH SCAR 16S?

The SCAR 16S is praised for being very lightweight with excellent recoil management. Its controls are familiar to AR-15 users, and the selector lever is well-positioned to avoid interfering with the firing finger.

What are the key disadvantages of the FNH SCAR 16S?

Key complaints include the reciprocating charging handle, which can strike the user's thumb or cause malfunctions, and the rear sight's tendency to flip down easily. It also requires modification to run PMAGs safely.

What are the main advantages of the Bushmaster ACR?

The ACR features a non-reciprocating charging handle and a much sturdier, highly adjustable stock. It offers a quick-change barrel system and a nitrided 1:9 twist barrel.

What are the key disadvantages of the Bushmaster ACR?

The ACR is roughly a pound heavier than the SCAR and feels nose-heavy. The reviewer criticizes the included Magpul backup sights as low quality and dislikes how the selector lever hits his finger when set to 'fire'.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Military Arms Channel

View all →