Smith & Wesson M&P 2 0 vs Gen 3 Model 5903 : Old vs New

Published on December 13, 2023
Duration: 27:20

This video compares the modern Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 striker-fired pistol with the older, Gen 3 Smith & Wesson 5903 double-single action pistol. It highlights key differences in operating systems, materials (polymer vs. aluminum frame), ergonomics, controls, and trigger mechanisms. While the M&P 2.0 represents current market trends with its lightweight polymer construction and consistent trigger pull, the 5903 showcases classic design elements and a different manual of arms, proving that older designs can still be viable self-defense options.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 is a modern polymer-framed, striker-fired pistol known for its consistent trigger pull and ergonomic design. In contrast, the Gen 3 5903 is an older aluminum-framed, double-single action pistol featuring an exposed hammer, a decocker, and a magazine disconnect safety, offering a different manual of arms and shooting experience.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: M&P 2.0 vs Gen 3 5903
  2. 01:11Pistol Overviews: Striker Fire vs. Double Single Action
  3. 02:27Smith & Wesson History: From Model 59 to Gen 3
  4. 04:03Key Similarities: Caliber and Capacity
  5. 04:22Operating Systems: Striker Fire vs. Hammer Fired
  6. 04:44Trigger Comparison: DA/SA vs. Striker Fire
  7. 05:26Safety Features: Decocker and Trigger Pull
  8. 07:00Magazine Disconnect Safety on the 5903
  9. 07:32Ergonomics and Grip Design
  10. 08:57Beaver Tail and Grip Texture
  11. 09:26Accessory Rails and Cocking Serrations
  12. 10:44Grip Angle Comparison
  13. 11:04Sights: Novak Style vs. Standard
  14. 11:26External Controls: Decockers and Slide Stops
  15. 12:00Magazine Release and Takedown Levers
  16. 12:34Magazine Differences
  17. 12:52Slide Finishes: Raw Stainless vs. Armor-Tuff
  18. 13:02Optics Ready Capability
  19. 13:19Trigger Pull Measurement
  20. 13:37M&P 2.0 Trigger Break and Reset
  21. 13:455903 Trigger Pull Weights (DA/SA)
  22. 14:27M&P 2.0 Trigger Pull Weight
  23. 14:37Weight Comparison: M&P 2.0 vs 5903 vs 5906
  24. 15:33Range Test: Shooting Impressions
  25. 15:56Recoil and Handling Differences
  26. 16:18Manual of Arms: DA/SA vs. Striker Fire
  27. 18:01Field Stripping: M&P 2.0
  28. 18:17Field Stripping: Gen 3 5903
  29. 19:16Rail Length and Frame Fit
  30. 19:59Internal Differences: Striker vs. Hammer Systems
  31. 20:30Reassembly Guide
  32. 21:35Price Comparison: M&P 2.0 vs 5903
  33. 22:20Pros and Cons Summary
  34. 25:05Conclusion: Old School vs. New State-of-the-Art

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 and the Gen 3 5903?

The M&P 2.0 is a polymer-framed, striker-fired pistol with a consistent trigger pull and modern features like an accessory rail. The Gen 3 5903 is an aluminum-framed, double-single action pistol with an exposed hammer, a decocker, and a magazine disconnect safety, representing older firearm design principles.

How do the trigger pulls compare on the M&P 2.0 and the 5903?

The M&P 2.0 offers a consistent trigger pull around 4.5-5 lbs. The 5903 has a long, heavy double-action pull (approx. 10.75 lbs) for the first shot, followed by a lighter, shorter single-action pull (approx. 5.25 lbs) for subsequent shots.

Is the Gen 3 Smith & Wesson 5903 still a viable self-defense option?

Yes, the Gen 3 5903 is considered a viable self-defense option. While it lacks some modern features like an accessory rail and has a different operating system, its robust construction, 9mm caliber, and 15+1 capacity make it capable, especially with proper training for its DA/SA trigger.

What are the advantages of the M&P 2.0's polymer frame over the 5903's aluminum frame?

The M&P 2.0's polymer frame makes it lighter and generally more ergonomic, with features like interchangeable backstraps for a customized grip. The aluminum frame of the 5903 adds weight but contributes to a flatter shooting profile and can be more durable over extreme round counts.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from sootch00

View all →