The Truth about S&W Revolvers - 586 L Comp 357 Magnum Review

Published on May 18, 2025
Duration: 17:57

This review of the Smith & Wesson 586 L Comp by Nightwood Guns highlights its potential as a carry revolver, particularly for its .357 Magnum power and integral compensator. However, the presenter, Brett, emphasizes significant quality control issues with modern S&W revolvers, including timing problems, cosmetic defects, and trigger reset issues, necessitating aftermarket modifications for optimal performance. Despite these drawbacks, the underlying design of the S&W revolver is praised for its durability, ergonomics, and fast trigger reset.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson 586 L Comp .357 Magnum is praised for its powerful .357 Magnum ballistics and effective integral compensator, but suffers from significant modern quality control issues. Recommended modifications include upgraded sights and specialized grips for optimal carry and performance.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Modern S&W Quality
  2. 01:58Modern Smith & Wesson Quality Control Issues
  3. 04:02Critique of Stock Sights & Upgrades
  4. 05:56Why Choose a Modern S&W Revolver?
  5. 06:26586 L Comp Features & Frame Size
  6. 07:19586 L Comp vs. Model 19 L Comp
  7. 08:15Concealed Carry Method
  8. 08:30Integral Compensator Explained
  9. 08:58.357 Magnum Ballistics & Loads
  10. 10:10Compensator Effectiveness & Muzzle Flash
  11. 11:07Full Lug Barrel & Finish
  12. 11:41Included Grips & Concealment Issues
  13. 12:17Recommended Concealed Carry Grips
  14. 13:15Performance Center Trigger & Action
  15. 14:26Cylinder Release & Ignition System
  16. 15:24Recommendation & Asterisks
  17. 15:37Vintage vs. Modern S&W Value
  18. 16:04Shooting Performance & Carry Choice
  19. 16:28Final Recommendation & Effort
  20. 17:06Conclusion & Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main quality control issues with modern Smith & Wesson revolvers?

Modern Smith & Wesson revolvers, even Performance Center models, frequently exhibit timing problems in the cylinder, cosmetic defects like scratches and nicks, and trigger reset issues. The presenter found it took years and multiple rejections to find an acceptable unit.

How effective is the integral compensator on the S&W 586 L Comp?

The single-port integral compensator on the 586 L Comp is effective with full-power .357 Magnum loads, significantly reducing muzzle rise and allowing for quicker follow-up shots. This feature is a key reason for its suitability as a carry revolver.

What are the recommended modifications for the Smith & Wesson 586 L Comp?

The presenter strongly recommends upgrading the sights to an SDM Goldbead front and DNL Sports rear sight for better visibility. Additionally, specialized rubber boot grips designed by Craig Spiegel are advised for improved concealment and handling.

Why does the presenter carry the 586 L Comp despite its flaws?

Despite quality control issues, the presenter carries the 586 L Comp because its underlying design offers superior ballistic performance with .357 Magnum, manageable recoil due to its weight and compensator, and excellent ergonomics. It's considered a 'workhorse' that can be used without worry.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Nightwood Guns

View all →