TOP 5 .357 Magnum Revolvers That Only Idiots Will Buy

Published on June 26, 2025
Duration: 13:28

This review highlights five .357 Magnum revolvers to avoid due to significant quality control, reliability, or design flaws. Models like the Taurus Defender 605 and Charter Arms Mag Pug suffer from inconsistent manufacturing and trigger issues, while the ultra-light S&W 360 PD and Ruger LCR present brutal recoil and critical functional problems. Even the innovative Chiappa Rhino is criticized for its stiff trigger and high price point.

Quick Summary

Five .357 Magnum revolvers to avoid include the Taurus Defender 605 (quality issues), Charter Arms Mag Pug (high returns), Chiappa Rhino (stiff trigger, high price), S&W 360 PD (brutal recoil), and Ruger LCR (false trigger reset). These models exhibit significant reliability, design, or quality control flaws.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: .357 Mag Revolvers to Avoid
  2. 00:43No. 5: Taurus Defender 605 Issues
  3. 03:00No. 4: Charter Arms Mag Pug Problems
  4. 05:44No. 3: Chiappa Rhino Trigger & Bore Axis
  5. 08:05No. 2: S&W 360 PD Recoil & Durability
  6. 10:28No. 1: Ruger LCR False Reset Issue

Frequently Asked Questions

Which .357 Magnum revolvers are considered poor buys due to quality issues?

The Taurus Defender 605 and Charter Arms Mag Pug are frequently cited for inconsistent quality control, rough finishing, and reliability problems like misfires or trigger malfunctions. These models often require specific ammo or have high warranty return rates.

What are the main drawbacks of the Chiappa Rhino and S&W Model 360 PD?

The Chiappa Rhino suffers from a stiff trigger and a high bore axis causing low point-of-impact, making it expensive for its usability flaws. The S&W 360 PD, while light, delivers brutal recoil and faces durability issues like flame cutting.

Why is the Ruger LCR listed as a .357 Magnum to avoid?

The Ruger LCR's lightweight polymer frame leads to harsh recoil. More critically, it can experience a 'false trigger reset,' where a click is felt before the trigger is fully reset, potentially causing a failure to fire in stressful situations.

What common problems affect the Taurus Defender 605 and Charter Arms Mag Pug?

The Taurus Defender 605 has inconsistent quality control and a heavy trigger. The Charter Arms Mag Pug is known for a high warranty return rate, light primer strikes, and trigger jamming issues, indicating significant build quality concerns.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Guns You Can't Live Without

View all →