Ultimate 22lr Ammo Test (Federal Punch Vs CCI Stinger)

Published on August 17, 2022
Duration: 6:02

This video conducts a comparative test of .22LR defensive ammunition, focusing on Federal Punch, CCI Stinger, and Winchester Velocitor. The tests involve shooting through 25-pound clay blocks and water jugs to assess penetration and expansion. The Federal Punch, despite its lighter weight and flat nose, demonstrated significant expansion and penetration, leading the instructor to consider it a top carry option. The CCI Stinger also showed good energy dump but less penetration than the Punch in the water jug test. The Winchester Velocitor was noted for its effectiveness but was edged out by the others in this specific comparison.

Quick Summary

Federal Punch .22LR ammunition is highlighted as a top choice for personal defense due to its 29-grain flat-nose projectile, which demonstrated effective energy dump, significant expansion in clay, and good penetration through water jugs. This performance suggests it balances expansion with follow-through energy, making it a strong contender for defensive carry, especially from shorter barrels.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Ultimate .22LR Defensive Test
  2. 00:42Test Setup: 7 Yards, 25lb Clay Blocks
  3. 00:47Velocitor Test Results
  4. 01:34CCI Stinger Test Results
  5. 02:45Federal Punch Test Results
  6. 03:53Water Jug Test: Stinger vs. Federal Punch
  7. 04:27CCI Stinger Water Jug Impact
  8. 04:53Federal Punch Water Jug Impact
  9. 05:17Conclusion: Top Defensive .22LR Ammunition

Frequently Asked Questions

Which .22LR ammunition is best for personal defense based on this test?

Based on this test, Federal Punch .22LR is a top contender for personal defense due to its effective energy dump, significant expansion in clay, and good penetration through water jugs. CCI Stinger also performed well, particularly in energy dump, but showed less penetration. Winchester Velocitor was effective but slightly edged out by the other two in this comparison.

How did Federal Punch .22LR perform in penetration tests?

In the clay block test, Federal Punch .22LR punched straight through and then through the other side. In the water jug test, it punched clean through two jugs, indicating good penetration capability for defensive use.

What are the key differences between CCI Stinger and Federal Punch .22LR for defense?

The CCI Stinger is a 32-grain hollow point that dumps energy effectively, creating a large wound channel in clay. The Federal Punch is a lighter 29-grain flat-nose projectile that offers good penetration and expansion, punching through both clay and water jugs. The flat nose of the Federal Punch may also contribute to better feeding reliability.

Are .22LR handguns recommended for personal defense?

The instructor uses .22LR handguns for personal defense in specific scenarios like backpacking or camping, often with compact firearms. While not a primary choice for everyone, the effectiveness of ammunition like Federal Punch and CCI Stinger makes them viable options for these niche applications.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from 704 TACTICAL

View all →