WALKING DEAD Season 3 Ep. 4 - "Killer Within" Review By MRCOLIONNOIR

Published on November 5, 2012
Duration: 13:24

This review by Colion Noir dissects The Walking Dead Season 3 Episode 4, 'Killer Within,' with a critical eye on plot, character development, and particularly, firearm handling. Noir, an expert in firearms, highlights unrealistic depictions of weapon manipulation, such as poor muzzle control and impractical holster use, while also commenting on character decisions and narrative pacing. The episode's events, including T-Dog's sacrifice and Lori's childbirth, are analyzed through Noir's experienced lens.

Quick Summary

Firearms expert Colion Noir critiques The Walking Dead S3E4, 'Killer Within,' focusing on unrealistic firearm handling like poor muzzle control and impractical holster use. He analyzes character arcs, including T-Dog's sacrifice and the Governor's deception, while also discussing narrative pacing and specific weapon models like the Colt Python and S&W Lady Smith.

Chapters

  1. 00:08Episode Introduction & Irony
  2. 00:47Plot Summary - Prison Life
  3. 01:11Rick's Cop Instincts
  4. 01:21Prisoner Negotiations & T-Dog's Stance
  5. 01:40Rick's Decision & Michonne's Investigation
  6. 01:57Governor's Deception
  7. 02:10Episode Pacing Critique
  8. 02:30Hershel's Resilience
  9. 02:45Michonne & Andrea's Future
  10. 03:22Prison Attack Begins
  11. 04:08Cross-Draw Holster Critique
  12. 04:41Firearm Handling in Show
  13. 05:24Hershel's Daughter's Inaction
  14. 05:57Rick's Holster & Muzzle Control
  15. 06:31T-Dog's Sacrifice - Initial Reaction
  16. 07:01T-Dog's Death Details
  17. 07:16Woodbury Plot Interruption
  18. 07:42Prison Chaos Escalates & Rick's Muzzle Control
  19. 08:19Sabotage and Reloading
  20. 08:43T-Dog's Heroic Death
  21. 09:06Lori's Childbirth Scene
  22. 09:49Woodbury Plot & Andrea's Indecision
  23. 10:16Zombie Gatekeeper Revealed & Black Man Quota
  24. 11:39Lori's Choice & C-Section
  25. 12:49Rick's Meltdown & Episode Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main criticisms of firearm handling in The Walking Dead Season 3 Episode 4?

Firearms expert Colion Noir criticizes unrealistic holster use, specifically Maggie's awkward cross-draw, and poor muzzle control demonstrated by Rick Grimes, who sweeps his weapon indiscriminately. Carl's recoil simulation is also mocked.

How is T-Dog's death portrayed and analyzed in the review?

Colion Noir expresses frustration over T-Dog's early death but praises his heroic sacrifice to save Carol. He details T-Dog using a Smith & Wesson Lady Smith before succumbing to a walker bite, highlighting the character's bravery.

What are the key plot points discussed in the review of The Walking Dead S3E4?

The review covers the introduction of new prisoners, Rick's distrust of them, Michonne's investigation at the Governor's compound, the prison attack, Lori's childbirth, and the reveal of a zombie gatekeeper. The pacing between the prison and Woodbury plots is also critiqued.

Which firearms are mentioned or visible in the review of The Walking Dead S3E4?

The review specifically mentions and critiques the handling of Rick's Colt Python and T-Dog's use of a Smith & Wesson Lady Smith. A Glock pistol is also noted as visible in the background.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Colion Noir

View all →