Which Handgun Should Replace SIG M17 for U.S. Military?

Published on May 24, 2025
Duration: 13:53

This video discusses whether the U.S. Military should replace the SIG M17 (a variant of the P320) with a different handgun. The host and viewer comments explore various alternatives, including different calibers (10mm, .40 S&W), platforms (hammer-fired), and specific models like the Beretta APX A1, Beretta PX4, Glock 20, and FN 57. While the M17 is considered a decent, lightweight, and inexpensive option, the discussion highlights potential improvements in firepower and caliber diversity.

Quick Summary

The U.S. military's SIG M17 handgun, a variant of the P320, is a lightweight, inexpensive, and easy-to-use firearm. While considered decent, discussions explore potential replacements to adopt more powerful calibers like 10mm or .40 S&W, or different platforms, though NATO's 9mm standardization is a significant factor.

Chapters

  1. 00:07Introduction: M17 Replacement Debate
  2. 00:47Host's Opinion: Keep the M17
  3. 01:11Desire for Caliber Change: 10mm or .40 S&W
  4. 01:40NATO Influence on Caliber Choice
  5. 02:01M17's Suitability for Modern Military
  6. 02:32Viewer Suggestion: Beretta APX A1
  7. 03:43Viewer Suggestion: Beretta PX4
  8. 05:03Viewer Argument: Military Trials & Choices
  9. 05:37Viewer Suggestion: Glock 17 Gen 5 FDE
  10. 05:53Viewer Suggestion: Glock 20 for Military
  11. 06:31Viewer Desire for .40 Caliber
  12. 06:53Viewer Suggestion: CZ P10 or FN 57
  13. 07:24Analysis of FN 5.7x28mm Round
  14. 08:15Viewer Suggestion: CZ75 SP-01
  15. 09:38Viewer Suggestion: Kel-Tec P57
  16. 10:21Viewer Suggestion: 1911 in .38 Super or 10mm
  17. 10:53Viewer Suggestion: High Point 'Yeet Cannon'
  18. 11:40Humorous Suggestion: Bow and Arrow
  19. 12:11Call to Action: Viewer Opinions

Frequently Asked Questions

Should the U.S. military replace the SIG M17 handgun?

The U.S. military's SIG M17, a variant of the P320, is a lightweight and inexpensive option. While considered decent, some argue for a switch to a different caliber like 10mm or .40 S&W for increased power, though NATO standardization on 9mm remains a hurdle.

What are some alternative handguns suggested to replace the SIG M17 for the U.S. military?

Viewer suggestions for replacing the SIG M17 include the Beretta APX A1, Beretta PX4, Glock 17 Gen 5, Glock 20 (in 10mm), FN 57, CZ P10, CZ75 SP-01, and even a 1911 in 10mm. Each has different strengths regarding caliber, platform, and cost.

Why might the U.S. military consider switching from the SIG M17?

A primary driver for switching from the SIG M17 could be to adopt a more powerful caliber like 10mm Auto or .40 S&W, potentially boosting these rounds' market presence. Another reason could be a preference for a different platform, such as hammer-fired designs, or a desire for an 'American-made' firearm.

What are the arguments for keeping the SIG M17 handgun in service?

Arguments for keeping the SIG M17 include its low cost, lightweight design, ease of use, and high round capacity. The military version also features manual safeties, addressing some concerns about the P320 platform. It's seen as a practical, modern choice that meets current needs.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →