Which would you rather have? (Benelli M4 vs Mossberg 590R)

Published on March 24, 2026
Duration: 1:23

This video compares the Benelli M4 autoloader and the Mossberg 590R pump-action shotgun for home defense. Both firearms are presented as substantially similar in capacity and ability to fire 3-inch shells. The presenter notes a slightly faster shooting experience with the Benelli M4 during a three-round test firing slugs.

Quick Summary

The Benelli M4 is an autoloader, while the Mossberg 590R is a pump-action shotgun. Both are presented as comparable for home defense, firing 3-inch shells and holding similar ammunition capacities. The Benelli M4 was noted as being slightly faster to shoot during a three-round test with slugs.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Autoloader vs Pump Shotgun for Home Defense
  2. 00:10Mossberg 590R with Folding Stock
  3. 00:15Benelli M4 with Collapsible Stock
  4. 00:19Mossberg 590R: Pump Action
  5. 00:21Benelli M4: Autoloader
  6. 00:26Ammunition Capacity Comparison
  7. 00:293-inch Shell Capability
  8. 00:31Three Rounds on Target Test
  9. 00:35Mossberg 590R Firing Test
  10. 00:51Shooting Slugs
  11. 00:56Benelli M4 Firing Test
  12. 01:14Speed Comparison: Benelli M4 vs Mossberg 590R
  13. 01:18Pump vs Auto: Which Would You Rather Have?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between the Benelli M4 and the Mossberg 590R for home defense?

The primary difference is their action type: the Benelli M4 is an autoloader, utilizing gas operation to cycle rounds, while the Mossberg 590R is a pump-action shotgun, requiring manual manipulation of the forend to chamber new shells.

Are the Benelli M4 and Mossberg 590R similar in terms of ammunition capacity and shell compatibility?

Yes, the video states that both shotguns are substantially similar in ammunition capacity and both are capable of firing 3-inch shells, making them comparable for home defense scenarios.

Which shotgun was faster to shoot in the comparison test?

During a three-round test firing slugs, the presenter noted that they were a little bit faster with the Benelli M4 autoloader compared to the Mossberg 590R pump-action shotgun.

What types of ammunition were used in the shotgun comparison?

In the comparison test between the Benelli M4 and the Mossberg 590R, slugs were used for firing on target. The video mentions this choice as part of their testing methodology.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from USCCA

View all →