Will the Ruger LCP unseat the S&W Bodyguard 1.0 as my pocket carry? Part 2 - range time

Published on March 28, 2026
Duration: 7:50

This video compares the Ruger LCP and Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 1.0 for pocket carry. The reviewer found the Bodyguard 1.0 to be more accurate and comfortable to shoot due to its better sights and smoother trigger, despite experiencing some light primer strikes with subpar ammunition. The LCP was deemed extremely reliable, though its trigger pinch and less visible sights impacted accuracy. Both firearms performed reliably with quality ammunition.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 1.0 generally offers better accuracy than the Ruger LCP due to its superior sights. While the LCP is highly reliable, the Bodyguard 1.0 can be prone to light primer strikes with low-quality ammunition, though it performs well with good self-defense rounds. Comfort during shooting also favors the Bodyguard 1.0, as the LCP's trigger can pinch the shooter's finger.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: LCP vs Bodyguard 1.0
  2. 00:31Ammunition Issues: New Republic Ammo
  3. 01:09Ruger LCP Range Performance
  4. 01:21LCP Slide Chambering Issues
  5. 02:05LCP Trigger Feel and Pinches
  6. 02:42LCP Accuracy at 40 Feet
  7. 03:09LCP Sight Visibility Issues
  8. 03:43Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 1.0 Range Performance
  9. 03:48Bodyguard 1.0 Double Strike Capability
  10. 04:04Bodyguard 1.0 Light Load Issues
  11. 04:37Bodyguard 1.0 with Quality Ammo
  12. 04:56Bodyguard 1.0 Accuracy Comparison
  13. 05:05Bodyguard 1.0 Sights and Trigger
  14. 05:20Bodyguard 1.0 Comfort and Accuracy
  15. 06:26Side-by-Side Target Comparison
  16. 06:52Reliability Summary: Ammo Dependent
  17. 07:24Final Takeaway: Shooter Comfort and Reliability

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is more accurate, the Ruger LCP or the S&W Bodyguard 1.0?

In this reviewer's hands, the Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 1.0 proved to be more accurate. This was attributed to its taller, drift-adjustable sights, which were easier to acquire quickly compared to the Ruger LCP's less visible sights, especially in challenging lighting conditions.

How reliable is the Ruger LCP compared to the S&W Bodyguard 1.0?

The Ruger LCP was found to be extremely reliable, handling nearly 200 rounds without significant issues. The S&W Bodyguard 1.0 experienced some malfunctions, specifically light primer strikes, when using subpar ammunition with hard primers, but performed reliably with quality self-defense rounds.

What are the comfort differences when shooting the Ruger LCP and S&W Bodyguard 1.0?

The reviewer experienced discomfort with the Ruger LCP's trigger, noting it pinched the tip of their finger during live fire. The S&W Bodyguard 1.0's trigger was described as smoother and more comfortable, not causing the same pinching sensation.

What impact does ammunition quality have on the S&W Bodyguard 1.0?

Ammunition quality significantly impacts the S&W Bodyguard 1.0. While it experienced light primer strikes and occasional cycling issues with 'subpar' New Republic ammunition due to hard primers, it functioned flawlessly with quality rounds like Winchester White Box and Hornady self-defense loads.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Cranky Gun Reviews

View all →