XDS vs. 1911

Published on September 20, 2012
Duration: 3:33

This video compares the Springfield Armory XDS pistol with a 1911 platform, focusing on their suitability for concealed carry. The XDS is highlighted as a modern polymer alternative to the traditional 1911, offering a thinner profile, lighter weight, and simplified operation without an external thumb safety. Both firearms are chambered in .45 ACP and are single-stack designs, but the XDS is noted for its reduced grip height, making it more concealable.

Quick Summary

The Springfield Armory XDS is a modern polymer pistol alternative to the 1911 for concealed carry, chambered in .45 ACP. It's thinner, lighter, and has a reduced grip height for better concealment, while also simplifying operation by omitting an external thumb safety.

Chapters

  1. 00:04Springfield Armory & 1911 Introduction
  2. 00:15XDS: Modern Polymer .45 ACP Option
  3. 00:33XDS vs. 1911: Size and Weight
  4. 00:56Concealed Carry Simplifications on XDS
  5. 01:18Shooting Comparison: 1911 vs. XDS
  6. 01:47Recoil and Handling Impressions
  7. 02:00Capacity and Grip Height Differences
  8. 02:10Concealment Advantages of XDS Grip
  9. 02:46Overall Feel and Concealability
  10. 02:56Purpose-Built for Concealed Carry
  11. 03:06Conclusion: XDS for 1911 Fans

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main advantages of the Springfield Armory XDS for concealed carry compared to a 1911?

The XDS offers a thinner profile, is lighter, and features a significantly reduced grip height, making it more concealable. It also simplifies operation by omitting an external thumb safety, which can be a snag point.

Is the Springfield XDS a .45 ACP caliber firearm?

Yes, the Springfield Armory XDS discussed in this video is a .45 ACP caliber pistol. It is presented as an option for those who like the .45 ACP round but prefer a modern polymer platform over a traditional 1911.

How does the recoil of the Springfield XDS compare to a compact 1911 in .45 ACP?

During shooting comparisons, the participants noted that there was 'not a lot of difference' in the felt recoil between the Springfield XDS and the compact 1911 pistol when both were chambered in .45 ACP.

What makes the Springfield XDS thinner than a 1911?

The XDS is thinner due to its polymer construction and the absence of an external thumb safety. The external thumb safety on a 1911 needs to protrude for usability, adding width, which is eliminated on the XDS.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Gun Talk Media

View all →