Carrying a Single-Action for Self-Defense — GMP #272

Published on March 1, 2025
Duration: 35:05

This podcast episode delves into the controversial topic of carrying a single-action revolver for self-defense. Hosts Brent Wheat and Roy Huntington, drawing on decades of shooting experience and historical context, explore the practicalities and potential pitfalls. They emphasize that while carrying a single-action is *possible*, the crucial question is *should* you, particularly for new shooters. The discussion highlights the importance of proficiency, understanding firearm limitations, and the tactical considerations involved in using older firearm designs in modern self-defense scenarios.

Quick Summary

Carrying a single-action revolver for self-defense is possible but not generally recommended, especially for new shooters. While experienced individuals can become proficient, the platform's weight, bulk, and slower reload times present significant challenges compared to modern firearms. Practicality and a deep understanding of the firearm's limitations are crucial for any defensive use.

Chapters

  1. 00:04Introduction to Single Action Self-Defense
  2. 00:54Sponsor: Armasight
  3. 01:35The 'Hate Mail' Prompt
  4. 02:01Can vs. Should You Carry a Single Action?
  5. 03:47Expert Opinion: No, But...
  6. 04:02Advice for New Shooters
  7. 04:41Demographics and Location Matter
  8. 06:05Balancing Mystique with Reality
  9. 06:35The Weight and Bulk of Single Actions
  10. 07:05Evolution of Concealed Carry Guns
  11. 08:43Historical Context: Black Powder Era
  12. 10:09The Cycle of Gun Design
  13. 11:27Modern Defensive Shooting Realities
  14. 12:13SASS vs. Defensive Fighting
  15. 13:39Can You? Yes. Should You? Explore.
  16. 14:08Replicating Real-World Gunfights
  17. 15:11Manipulating Guns Under Stress
  18. 16:04Simulating a Saloon Shootout
  19. 17:05Black Powder Concussive Force
  20. 18:04Learning from Historical Tactics
  21. 18:54Frank Hamer's Choice
  22. 20:28Tactics Around Single Actions
  23. 20:57Speed Loading Lever Actions
  24. 21:52Limitations and Confidence
  25. 23:09Hammer Cocking Techniques
  26. 23:50The Musician Analogy
  27. 24:47Proficiency is Key
  28. 25:24Real-World Limitations
  29. 29:27Carrying Two Short Barrel SA's
  30. 30:16No Clear-Cut Rules
  31. 30:41The 'Binary' Gun Owner
  32. 31:18The Real World is Gray
  33. 32:21Closing Thoughts on Equipment vs. Skill
  34. 33:23Housekeeping and Sponsor

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it advisable for new shooters to carry a single-action revolver for self-defense?

No, it is strongly advised against. New shooters often lack fundamental firearm handling skills, and the manual of arms for a single-action revolver is more complex than for modern semi-automatic pistols or double-action revolvers, making it unsuitable for beginners.

What are the main challenges of carrying a single-action revolver for self-defense?

The primary challenges include their often significant weight and bulk, slower reloading process compared to modern firearms, and the need for a high level of proficiency to operate effectively under stress. The romantic appeal must be balanced with practical self-defense considerations.

Can experienced shooters effectively use single-action revolvers for self-defense?

Yes, experienced shooters who are highly proficient with single-action revolvers can potentially use them for self-defense. However, they must still critically assess the platform's limitations, such as capacity and reload speed, and ensure their training accounts for these factors in realistic scenarios.

What historical context supports the idea of using older firearms for self-defense?

Historically, even large firearms like the Colt Single Action Army were carried, but the trend quickly shifted towards smaller, more concealable guns like derringers. This indicates that practicality and concealability have always been factors in defensive firearm choices, even in the 19th century.

More Self Defense Videos You Might Like

More from GUNS and American Handgunner Magazines

View all →