Best speed loaders: Safariland, HKS, and five-star tradeoffs

Published on March 8, 2026
Duration: 0:59

This expert-level guide, informed by TheYankeeMarshal's extensive experience, compares popular speed loader brands: Safariland, HKS, and Five-Star. It highlights the functional differences, particularly the ease of use between Safariland's 'pop-down' release and the twisting mechanism of HKS and Five-Star. The speaker, an experienced firearm enthusiast, offers practical insights into choosing the most efficient speed loader for revolver owners.

Quick Summary

Safariland speed loaders are preferred for their convenient 'pop-down' release mechanism, which is faster and less prone to accidental cylinder manipulation compared to the twisting action of HKS and Five-Star speed loaders. While HKS and Five-Star have their merits, Safariland's design offers a more efficient and user-friendly experience for quick revolver reloads.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Favorite Speed Loader & Brand Discussion
  2. 00:13Speed Loaders vs. Speed Strips
  3. 00:28HKS Speed Loader Drawback
  4. 00:33Safariland Speed Loader Advantage
  5. 00:44Five-Star Speed Loaders & Design Wish

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main advantage of Safariland speed loaders?

Safariland speed loaders are favored for their 'pop-down' release mechanism. This design allows for quick and convenient ejection of rounds into the revolver cylinder without the risk of accidentally manipulating the cylinder itself, making reloads faster and more reliable.

What is a common drawback of HKS speed loaders?

A significant drawback of HKS speed loaders is the twisting action required to release the rounds. This can sometimes lead to the user inadvertently twisting the revolver's cylinder instead of just releasing the cartridges, which can slow down the reloading process.

How do Five-Star speed loaders compare to Safariland and HKS?

Five-Star speed loaders are noted for their aesthetic appeal, making them a good choice if appearance is a factor. However, like HKS, they require a twisting motion to release rounds, which is less convenient than the 'pop-down' mechanism found on Safariland speed loaders.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →