Freezing Rifle Test. (AK, AR-15, SCAR, FAL etc)

Published on January 2, 2022
Duration: 37:08

This guide details a rigorous cold-weather reliability test for various rifle platforms, as demonstrated by Garand Thumb. It outlines procedures for simulating freezing rain and extreme ice immersion to assess how different operating systems perform under harsh conditions. The test highlights the superior reliability of AK and AUG platforms in sub-arctic environments compared to many AR-15 variants.

Quick Summary

Garand Thumb's freezing rifle test revealed that AK platforms and the Steyr AUG excel in extreme cold due to superior mechanical leverage overcoming ice. AR-15s struggled with frozen safeties, triggers, and malfunctions, while the SCAR-H and M14 also failed under simulated freezing conditions.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to the Freezing Test
  2. 03:00Ammunition and Magazine Baseline
  3. 04:30Baseline Function Testing
  4. 10:01Phase 1: Freezing Rain Simulation
  5. 11:08Phase 1 Results
  6. 15:05Phase 2: Full Immersion Freezing
  7. 18:47Phase 2 Results and Final Assessment

Frequently Asked Questions

Which rifle platforms performed best in the Garand Thumb freezing test?

The AK platforms (AKM, AK-105) and the Steyr AUG demonstrated the best reliability in extreme cold-weather testing, successfully cycling even with significant internal ice. They showed superior mechanical leverage to overcome ice accumulation compared to other tested platforms.

What were the main failure points for AR-15s in the cold weather test?

AR-15 platforms experienced multiple issues, including frozen safeties, stuck magazine releases, frozen firing pins, and dead triggers. These malfunctions highlight potential vulnerabilities in extreme cold conditions for many AR-15 designs tested.

How did the SCAR-H and M14 perform in the freezing rifle test?

The FN SCAR-H failed the initial freezing rain simulation due to an extraction failure. The M14 also failed early on because its trigger mechanism froze solid, indicating susceptibility to extreme cold.

What is the significance of using worn rifles in the cold weather test?

Using well-worn rifles with high round counts (5,000-15,000 rounds) simulates real-world professional use, providing a more accurate assessment of reliability under harsh conditions than testing brand-new firearms.

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Garand Thumb

View all →