Is the .357 Magnum Snubnose Revolver a Bad Idea?

Published on June 25, 2021
Duration: 18:31

This video from TFB TV, featuring James Reeves, explores the viability of the .357 Magnum snubnose revolver, specifically the Smith & Wesson 340PD, for personal defense. The expert assessment highlights the challenges posed by extreme recoil and heavy trigger pull in such lightweight firearms, especially when firing full-power .357 Magnum rounds. Despite these difficulties, the testing demonstrated that acceptable accuracy can be maintained at defensive distances (20-30 feet) with significant shooter skill, though accuracy degrades at longer ranges (50 feet). The conclusion suggests that while potent, the .357 Magnum snubnose requires substantial training to manage effectively, and .38 Special may be a more practical choice for many users.

Quick Summary

The .357 Magnum snubnose revolver, particularly lightweight models like the S&W 340PD, presents a significant recoil challenge that impacts accuracy. While potent, effective use requires advanced shooter skill to manage the muzzle flip and heavy trigger. Testing shows accuracy is achievable at 20-30 feet, but degrades at 50 feet. For many, .38 Special offers a more practical balance for concealed carry.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Recoil
  2. 01:12Historical Context
  3. 02:25S&W 340PD Specs
  4. 03:28Control & Accuracy Experiment
  5. 05:06Range Testing Results
  6. 13:34Final Assessment

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the .357 Magnum snubnose revolver suitable for concealed carry?

While the .357 Magnum snubnose offers significant power, its extreme recoil in lightweight frames like the S&W 340PD makes it challenging to control for accurate follow-up shots. For many, .38 Special provides a more practical balance of power and shootability for concealed carry.

What are the main challenges of shooting a lightweight .357 Magnum snubnose?

The primary challenges are managing the intense felt recoil and the heavy double-action trigger pull. These factors, especially in ultra-lightweight firearms like the 11.75 oz S&W 340PD, can significantly degrade accuracy and shooter comfort during rapid fire.

Can you be accurate with a .357 Magnum snubnose at defensive distances?

Yes, at typical defensive ranges (20-30 feet), skilled shooters can maintain good accuracy on target. However, accuracy drops considerably at longer distances (50 feet) due to the difficulty in controlling the firearm's muzzle flip and recoil under stress.

What is the Smith & Wesson 340PD?

The Smith & Wesson 340PD is highlighted as the lightest .357 Magnum revolver ever made, weighing just 11.75 ounces due to its Scandium alloy frame and Titanium cylinder. It holds 5 rounds and is known for its potent combination of light weight and powerful cartridge, leading to brutal recoil.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TFB TV

View all →