Ken Hackathorn analyzes Red Dot Sights on handguns and gives the pros and cons - Masterclass EP 31

Published on October 19, 2022
Duration: 22:52

Ken Hackathorn, a master instructor with decades of experience, provides a pragmatic analysis of red dot sights (RDS) on handguns. He emphasizes that while RDS offer advantages, particularly at longer ranges, they present a significant learning curve for experienced shooters due to ingrained 'automaticity' with iron sights. Hackathorn stresses the necessity of extensive live fire training to master RDS re-acquisition after recoil and cautions against viewing RDS as a 'magic' fix for fundamental shooting deficiencies.

Quick Summary

Master instructor Ken Hackathorn advises that while red dot sights (RDS) offer advantages at longer ranges, they present a learning curve for experienced shooters due to ingrained iron sight habits. He stresses that RDS proficiency requires extensive live fire practice (thousands of rounds) and that enclosed emitters are preferred for defensive use due to environmental resilience.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: RDS Skepticism & Industry Hype
  2. 01:55Ken's RDS Pistol Setup & Testing Rounds
  3. 03:50The Learning Curve: New vs. Experienced Shooters
  4. 05:52Dry Fire vs. Live Fire for RDS Training
  5. 06:56RDS Advantage: Distance vs. Self-Defense Reality
  6. 07:29Cost, Quality, and Mounting Interfaces
  7. 08:47Proficiency is Perishable: The 99% Problem
  8. 12:07Enclosed vs. Open Emitter RDS
  9. 16:57Historical Context: RDS as a Trend?

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main challenges for experienced shooters transitioning to red dot sights (RDS) on handguns?

Experienced shooters often struggle with 'automaticity,' their ingrained habit of seeking the front sight. They must consciously retrain their brain to focus on the target and superimpose the red dot, which requires significant practice and can take thousands of rounds to feel natural.

When do red dot sights (RDS) offer a real advantage over traditional iron sights on a handgun?

Red dot sights provide a significant advantage in speed and accuracy at longer distances, typically 15-20 yards and beyond, due to the single aiming point. At closer self-defense distances (0-10 yards), the advantage over quality iron sights is minimal for most shooters.

What type of red dot sight does Ken Hackathorn recommend for defensive handguns?

Ken Hackathorn strongly prefers enclosed emitter red dot sights, such as the Aimpoint ACRO P2. These designs are more reliable in adverse conditions because the emitter and lens are protected from dust, lint, rain, and snow.

How much training is required to become proficient with a red dot sight on a handgun?

Proficiency with an RDS is a perishable skill requiring substantial training. Ken Hackathorn estimates it took him 1,000 rounds to become comfortable and 5,000 rounds for the RDS to feel natural, emphasizing that casual shooters may struggle under stress.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Wilson Combat

View all →