Laminated Steel Showdown: Cold Steel vs Fallkniven

Published on February 23, 2015
Duration: 29:36

This video provides an expert comparison of two high-end laminated steel fixed-blade knives: the Cold Steel SRK San Mai III and the Fallkniven S1 Forest Knife. Nutnfancy, a seasoned gear reviewer, analyzes their philosophy of use for survival and camp tasks, blade geometry, weight, ergonomics, and steel composition. The SRK is noted for its value and handle size, while the S1 is favored for weight-conscious backpackers.

Quick Summary

Expert reviewer Nutnfancy compares the Cold Steel SRK San Mai III and Fallkniven S1 Forest Knife, highlighting their laminated steel construction, blade geometry, and weight. The SRK offers superior value and a larger handle, while the S1 is lighter for backpacking. Both are considered robust 'woods blades' for survival tasks.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Contenders
  2. 04:36Contender Overview and Philosophy of Use
  3. 08:17Blade Geometry and Slicing Performance
  4. 10:18Weight and Ergonomics
  5. 12:19Steel Composition and Durability
  6. 15:13Competitive Options and Alternatives
  7. 17:16Value Assessment and Final Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference in steel composition between the Cold Steel SRK San Mai III and the Fallkniven S1?

The Cold Steel SRK San Mai III utilizes San Mai III steel with a VG-1 core, while the Fallkniven S1 features a laminated VG-10 core. Both are laminated steels designed for edge retention and toughness, though the high-hardness cores can be prone to chipping.

Which knife is lighter, the Cold Steel SRK or the Fallkniven S1?

The Fallkniven S1 is lighter, weighing 6.8 oz (knife only) and 9.8 oz with its sheath. The Cold Steel SRK San Mai III has a total carry weight of 11.2 oz, making the S1 a better option for weight-conscious backpackers.

What is the 'Philosophy of Use' discussed for these knives?

The 'Philosophy of Use' (POU) for these knives is defined as 'woods blades'—tools designed for survival and camp tasks like fire preparation, food prep, and general chores in wet or snowy environments where rust resistance is crucial. They are built for durability and heavy use.

What are the key advantages of the Cold Steel SRK San Mai III over the Fallkniven S1?

The Cold Steel SRK San Mai III offers a significant value advantage, priced around $100 compared to the Fallkniven S1's $160. It also features a larger handle with more 'real estate', which can be beneficial for users with larger hands.

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from nutnfancy

View all →