Mud Test: Mattel Death Trap! (The Vietnam Era AR15/M16)

Published on December 24, 2016
Duration: 13:51

This guide details a rigorous mud test procedure for a Vietnam-era Colt SP1 AR-15, demonstrating its reliability even when heavily fouled. The test, conducted by InRangeTV hosts Ian McCollum and Karl Kasarda, debunks the 'Mattel Death Trap' myth. It highlights the AR-15's sealed design advantages in muddy conditions compared to the AK-47, while also explaining historical reliability issues stemming from ammunition changes and lack of maintenance kits during the Vietnam War.

Quick Summary

A mud test on a Vietnam-era Colt SP1 AR-15 demonstrated its surprising reliability, firing multiple magazines despite heavy fouling. Experts attribute early M16 failures to ammunition changes and maintenance issues, not design flaws, and note the AR-15's sealed receiver offers advantages in muddy conditions over the AK-47.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to the 'Mattel Death Trap' Myth
  2. 01:04Rifle Specifications and Authenticity
  3. 02:10Baseline Test and First Mud Application
  4. 03:43Extreme Mud Test: Open Dust Cover
  5. 04:48Reliability Analysis: AR vs. AK
  6. 06:56Historical Context of Vietnam Failures
  7. 09:05Interview with L. James Sullivan
  8. 11:50Bonus Test: Troy GAU-5/P Replica

Frequently Asked Questions

How did the Colt SP1 AR-15 perform in a mud test?

The Colt SP1 AR-15 performed exceptionally well in a rigorous mud test, firing multiple magazines even after being heavily fouled with mud, debunking the 'Mattel Death Trap' myth associated with early AR-15s.

Why were early M16 rifles unreliable in Vietnam?

Early M16 reliability issues in Vietnam were largely due to changes in gunpowder specifications affecting gas port pressure and dwell time, compounded by a lack of cleaning kits and chrome-lined chambers, rather than inherent design flaws.

Is the AR-15 more reliable than the AK-47 in muddy conditions?

The AR-15's sealed receiver design offers better protection against mud ingress compared to the AK-47's more open system, suggesting the AR-15 may be more reliable in extremely muddy environments if properly maintained.

Who is L. James Sullivan and what is his connection to the AR-15?

L. James Sullivan is recognized as an AR-15 designer who criticized the Army's handling of the rifle's rollout in Vietnam, citing 'criminal negligence' and bureaucratic decisions that negatively impacted its performance.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from InRangeTV

View all →