Revolver for EDC?? (POU DISCUSSION)

Published on February 18, 2024
Duration: 15:18

This video critically examines the practical use of revolvers for everyday carry (EDC) in 2024, arguing they are largely obsolete for self-defense compared to modern semi-automatic handguns. The presenter, an experienced firearm enthusiast, highlights revolvers' reliability issues, slow reloads, and limited capacity. He contrasts these with the advantages of semi-automatics like the Glock 19, emphasizing their superior capacity, ease of use, and compatibility with modern accessories like red dot sights and lights.

Quick Summary

Revolvers are generally not recommended for everyday carry (EDC) in 2024 due to significant reliability concerns, slow reloading times, and limited ammunition capacity compared to modern semi-automatic handguns like the Glock 19. While aesthetically pleasing, their practical effectiveness in self-defense scenarios is considered inferior.

Chapters

  1. 00:01Introduction: Revolver for EDC Discussion
  2. 00:13Realistic Use of Revolvers in 2024
  3. 01:36Featured Revolvers: S&W Model 36 & 686
  4. 02:20Presenter's Background with Revolvers
  5. 03:04Revolver Reloading Technique
  6. 03:42The Reliability Issue with Revolvers
  7. 04:10Understanding Timing Issues and Malfunctions
  8. 04:33Exposed Hammer and Dry Firing Warning
  9. 05:06Historical Context: Malfunctions and Backup Guns
  10. 05:33Revolvers: Beautiful but Not Reliable
  11. 05:47Pocket Gun Use Case and Double-Action Pull
  12. 06:15Reload Times and Weight Considerations
  13. 07:06Reasons Against Revolvers: Reloads & Weight
  14. 07:15.357 Magnum vs. 9mm Comparison
  15. 07:40Pros of Revolvers: Aesthetics & History
  16. 07:55Ammunition Prices for Revolvers
  17. 08:15Good Things About Revolvers: Stocks & Shooting
  18. 08:33Safety Note: Cylinder Out of Gun
  19. 09:08Revolvers for New Shooters
  20. 09:24Presenter's Recommendation: Glock 19
  21. 09:54Semi-Automatic Advantages: Reliability & Capacity
  22. 10:06Upgradability: Red Dots and Lights
  23. 10:26Ease of Use with Semi-Automatics
  24. 10:30Holster Compatibility: Revolvers vs. Semi-Autos
  25. 10:54Recommended Holsters: Safari Land & T-Rex Arms
  26. 11:33Appendix and Inside-the-Waistband Holster Options
  27. 12:30Glock 43X as a Carry Option
  28. 13:09Summary: Revolvers vs. Semi-Automatics for Defense
  29. 13:48The Unfortunate Reality of Modern Firearm Combat
  30. 14:12Viewer Engagement: Comments and Discussion
  31. 14:40Patreon and Discord Community
  32. 15:09Sign Off: Trench Grade Channel

Frequently Asked Questions

Are revolvers still viable for everyday carry (EDC) in 2024?

While revolvers possess aesthetic appeal and historical significance, this video argues they are largely not ideal for modern self-defense. Their inherent reliability issues, slow reloads, and limited capacity make them less practical compared to contemporary semi-automatic handguns like the Glock 19.

What are the main reliability concerns with revolvers for self-defense?

Revolvers can suffer from timing issues, especially when exposed to dirt or debris, leading to malfunctions like failures to fire or 'outer battery' detonations. These issues can render the firearm inoperable during a critical incident.

Why are semi-automatic handguns preferred over revolvers for EDC?

Semi-automatic handguns offer higher magazine capacity, faster and simpler reloads, and generally greater reliability. They also more easily accommodate modern accessories like red dot sights and weapon-mounted lights, enhancing their defensive capabilities.

What are the advantages of a Glock 19 for concealed carry?

The Glock 19 is highlighted for its balance of size and capacity, reliability, ease of use, and compatibility with various holsters and accessories. Its lightweight design also aids in comfortable concealed carry, even with extended magazines.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Trench Grenade

View all →