Should Carry Guns EVER Have a Manual Safety?..(And Why Shouldn't They?)

Published on January 18, 2025
Duration: 10:02

This video discusses the pros and cons of manual safeties on carry guns. The speaker, 'The Yankee Marshal,' argues against manual safeties for most carry guns, citing them as an additional point of failure in high-stress situations. He acknowledges arguments for safeties in specific scenarios like appendix carry or against gun grabs, but ultimately favors firearms with decockers or those without external safeties, like Glocks, for concealed carry.

Quick Summary

The Yankee Marshal argues against manual safeties on carry guns, viewing them as potential failure points in high-stress self-defense. He prefers firearms with decockers or those without external safeties, like Glocks, though acknowledges safeties may be considered for appendix carry or to prevent gun grabs.

Chapters

  1. 00:10Introduction: Manual Safeties on Carry Guns
  2. 00:33The Argument Against Manual Safeties
  3. 01:00Examples of Safety Failures
  4. 01:15The Case For Manual Safeties
  5. 02:06Counterarguments: Gun Grab Defense
  6. 03:01Carry Method and Safety Preferences
  7. 03:49Appendix Carry Considerations
  8. 04:25Viewer Opinions: 1911 Platform
  9. 05:08Viewer Opinions: Stressful Situations
  10. 05:35Smith & Wesson Revolver Safeties
  11. 06:06Off-Topic Viewer Question: 380 vs. Spork
  12. 06:29Off-Topic Viewer Question: Retention Holsters
  13. 07:26Glocks and External Safeties
  14. 07:56Speaker's Dislike for Striker-Fired Guns
  15. 08:02Conclusion: Personal Preference for Carry

Frequently Asked Questions

Should carry guns have manual safeties?

The speaker, 'The Yankee Marshal,' generally advises against manual safeties on carry guns. He believes they add an unnecessary step that can fail in high-stress self-defense situations, potentially hindering quick deployment. While acknowledging arguments for safeties in specific scenarios like appendix carry or preventing gun grabs, he prefers firearms with decockers or those without external safeties.

What are the arguments against manual safeties on carry guns?

The primary argument against manual safeties on carry guns is that they introduce an additional mechanical step that can be forgotten or fail under extreme stress, preventing the firearm from being fired when needed. This can be critical in rapid self-defense scenarios where time is of the essence.

Are there any situations where a manual safety is recommended for a carry gun?

Yes, manual safeties might be considered beneficial in specific situations. For instance, during appendix carry, where the risk of self-inflicted injury is higher, a manual safety could offer an extra layer of security. Additionally, some argue it can prevent an attacker from easily using the firearm against the owner if they grab it.

What alternatives to manual safeties does the speaker suggest for carry guns?

The speaker prefers firearms with decocker mechanisms, which allow the hammer to be safely dropped for a double-action first pull without an external safety lever. He also notes that firearms like Glocks, which lack external safeties, are a viable option for those who prefer to avoid manual safeties altogether.

Do revolvers typically have manual safeties?

No, revolvers generally do not come equipped with manual safeties. This is one reason why many individuals who prefer to carry firearms without manual safeties opt for revolvers.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →