Is BORE AXIS a MYTH? Testing Bore axis vs. Ergonomics vs. Weight

Published on December 3, 2021
Duration: 12:28

This video from The Humble Marksman debunks the myth of bore axis being the primary factor in recoil control, presenting data from practical shooting drills. The instructor, a USPSA Master, concludes that ergonomics and frame weight are more significant influences on a handgun's shootability and recovery time. The testing involved comparing various P320 configurations against a Glock 17 Gen 4, focusing on performance in a Bill Drill and a USPSA-style practical course.

Quick Summary

Expert analysis debunks the myth that low bore axis is paramount for handgun recoil control. Testing reveals that ergonomics and frame weight are far more influential factors in managing recoil and achieving faster follow-up shots. Superior grip, frame shape, and added mass contribute more to shootability than bore axis alone.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: The Bore Axis Debate
  2. 01:00Theories: Bore Axis vs. Ergonomics vs. Weight
  3. 03:08Testing Methodology: Drills and Scoring
  4. 03:59The Contenders: Handgun Configurations Tested
  5. 05:37Bill Drill Results Analysis
  6. 07:34Practical Drill Results Analysis
  7. 08:47Overall Performance Comparison
  8. 09:12Key Takeaways: What Really Matters
  9. 11:26Final Ranking of Factors
  10. 12:07Conclusion and Viewer Engagement

Frequently Asked Questions

Is bore axis the most important factor for handgun recoil control?

No, according to expert testing, bore axis is the least important factor for handgun recoil control. Ergonomics and frame weight have a significantly greater impact on a shooter's ability to manage recoil and achieve faster follow-up shots.

What factors are more important than bore axis for handgun recoil control?

Ergonomics, frame weight, and frame material are more critical for handgun recoil control than bore axis. Superior ergonomics allow for a better grip and control, while increased weight helps the firearm settle faster after each shot.

How does frame material affect handgun recoil?

Polymer frames absorb recoil by deforming and reforming, offering a softer impulse. Heavy metal frames, like alloy or brass, transmit recoil more directly but can help the gun settle faster due to their mass. The speaker prefers the more linear impact of alloy frames.

What is the best handgun configuration for recoil control based on this test?

The P320 AXG frame with brass grips was the top performer, offering superior ergonomics, excellent traction, and significant weight that greatly improved control and target recovery. This configuration was favored over lighter or lower bore axis options.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from TheHumbleMarksman

View all →