BREAKING: DOJ BEGS SCOTUS to reverse Pro Gun Decision… you are not going to believe this one!

Published on March 19, 2023
Duration: 6:07

The Department of Justice, led by Merrick Garland, has filed an accelerated request with the Supreme Court (SCOTUS) to review a Fifth Circuit ruling. This ruling found a federal law unconstitutional that prohibits individuals under domestic violence restraining orders from possessing firearms, emphasizing the lack of a conviction. The DOJ's action is seen as an attempt to prevent this decision from impacting the legality of Red Flag laws nationwide, which also raise due process concerns.

Quick Summary

The DOJ has requested an accelerated review from the Supreme Court regarding a Fifth Circuit ruling that declared a federal law unconstitutional. This law prohibited individuals under domestic violence restraining orders from possessing firearms, as it lacked a conviction requirement, raising concerns about the future of Red Flag laws.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: DOJ's SCOTUS Request
  2. 00:13Merrick Garland and Accelerated Request
  3. 00:19Supreme Court and the Bruin Decision
  4. 00:25Fifth Circuit Ruling on Domestic Violence Restraining Orders
  5. 00:37Implications for Red Flag Laws
  6. 00:57Sponsor: Battle Cat Company
  7. 01:38DOJ Seeks Fast Track Review of Gun Ban Ruling
  8. 01:45Synopsis of the Fifth Circuit Decision
  9. 02:07Focus on Lack of Conviction
  10. 02:14Gun Control Side's Reaction
  11. 02:32Framing of the Issue by the Left
  12. 02:51Justice Department's Petition Details
  13. 03:06Restraining Order vs. Conviction
  14. 03:15Importance of Conviction
  15. 03:26Parallel to Red Flag Law Due Process Issues
  16. 03:31States Using Red Flag Laws
  17. 03:46Risk of Homicide with Abusers and Guns
  18. 03:54Elizabeth Prelogar's Petition
  19. 04:00Urgency for Supreme Court Decision
  20. 04:07Challenging Core Tenets of Rights
  21. 04:16Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeal Ruling Details
  22. 04:26Worry of Wide Implications
  23. 04:29Discouraging Victims from Coming Forward
  24. 04:32Applicable States: Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi
  25. 04:39Reason for Expedited Case
  26. 04:48Impact on Red Flag Laws Nationally
  27. 04:57Further Implications of the Ruling
  28. 05:00Prelogar's Statement on Modern Statutes
  29. 05:07Modern Gun Regulations and Historical Forebears
  30. 05:14Bruin Decision's Impact on Gun Control
  31. 05:23History of Gun Control Legislation (NFA 1934)
  32. 05:36Undermining Gun Control Measures
  33. 05:43Unconstitutionality of Past Laws
  34. 05:48Bruin Decision's Broader Impact
  35. 05:53Restoring Second Amendment Rights
  36. 06:00Conclusion and Viewer Engagement

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the DOJ's main objective in asking the Supreme Court to review the Fifth Circuit's gun ruling?

The Department of Justice is urging the Supreme Court to fast-track its review of a Fifth Circuit decision that found a federal law unconstitutional. This law prohibited individuals under domestic violence restraining orders from possessing firearms, and the DOJ aims to prevent this ruling from impacting the legality of Red Flag laws nationwide.

Why is the Fifth Circuit's ruling on domestic violence restraining orders significant for gun rights?

The Fifth Circuit ruled that firearm rights should not be revoked without a criminal conviction. This decision is significant because it challenges the constitutionality of laws that disarm individuals based solely on a restraining order, raising due process concerns similar to those associated with Red Flag laws.

How might the Fifth Circuit's ruling affect Red Flag laws?

Gun control advocates fear that if the Fifth Circuit's ruling is upheld, it could lead to the nationwide invalidation of Red Flag laws. This is because both types of laws involve the potential removal of firearms without a prior criminal conviction, which the Fifth Circuit deemed unconstitutional.

What legal principle is central to the Fifth Circuit's decision regarding firearm possession?

The central legal principle is due process. The Fifth Circuit's decision emphasizes that individuals should not have their Second Amendment rights taken away without a conviction or a full judicial process that establishes guilt, aligning with traditional legal standards.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Langley Outdoors Academy

View all →