Cops Arresting People for Live Fire Training

Published on March 5, 2023
Duration: 10:19

This video critically examines the Suffolk County Police Department's (SCPD) policy of arresting individuals and instructors for participating in live-fire training, which is a mandatory requirement for obtaining a concealed carry license under New York's Concealed Carry Improvement Act (CCIA). The host, demonstrating expert knowledge of firearms law, highlights how SCPD allegedly ignores state law exemptions (Penal Law § 265.20(3-a)) and the implications of the Supreme Court's Bruen decision. The discussion centers around the 'Giambalvo v. New York' lawsuit, which seeks to challenge these allegedly unconstitutional enforcement practices.

Quick Summary

New York police, specifically in Suffolk County, are allegedly arresting individuals and instructors for participating in live-fire training required for concealed carry licenses. This action reportedly ignores state law exemptions like Penal Law § 265.20(3-a), which permit such training during the application process, leading to legal challenges like 'Giambalvo v. New York'.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Bait and Switch Tactic
  2. 00:21Channel Intro & Recording Conditions
  3. 01:02Sponsor: Armslist
  4. 01:35NY Arrest Policy for Training
  5. 02:16Pre-License Possession Catch-22
  6. 02:58Police Ignoring State Law Exemption
  7. 03:25Giambalvo v. New York Lawsuit
  8. 03:57Lawsuit Details: Unlicensed & Restricted
  9. 05:27Plaintiffs: Giambalvo & Malone
  10. 06:17Malone Declaration: Police Admissions
  11. 07:07Police Misinterpretation of Law
  12. 08:04Lawsuit Details: Lack of Correlation
  13. 09:26Case Progress: Appeal to Second Circuit
  14. 09:49Outro & Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are police arresting people for live-fire training in New York?

In Suffolk County, NY, police are reportedly arresting individuals and instructors for participating in live-fire training, even though it's a requirement for concealed carry licenses under the CCIA. This allegedly occurs despite state law exemptions like Penal Law § 265.20(3-a), which permit such training during the application process.

What is the legal basis for challenging SCPD's arrest policy for gun training?

The challenge is based on the argument that SCPD's policy violates New York State law, specifically Penal Law § 265.20(3-a), which exempts unlicensed individuals from arrest for live-fire training required for a license. The lawsuit 'Giambalvo v. New York' alleges this policy is unconstitutional and ignores established legal exemptions.

Does New York law allow training before getting a handgun license?

Yes, New York Penal Law § 265.20(3-a), enacted via the CCIA, explicitly exempts unlicensed individuals from criminal penalties when they engage in live-fire training as part of the concealed carry license application process. This exemption is intended to allow training before a permit is issued.

What is the significance of the Bruen decision in New York's gun laws?

The Supreme Court's Bruen decision affirmed the Second Amendment right to carry firearms in public for self-defense. In New York, it led to the CCIA, but legal challenges persist regarding whether law enforcement is correctly interpreting and applying the ruling, particularly concerning training requirements and license restrictions.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Liberty Doll

View all →