Gun Gripes #171: "NY S9191: Big Brother Wants Your Login"

Published on December 5, 2018
Duration: 20:57

This video from Iraqveteran8888 discusses New York Senate Bill 9191, which proposes requiring firearm purchasers to submit three years of social media history and search engine data. The hosts argue this bill infringes on Second and First Amendment rights, sets a dangerous precedent for government overreach, and could lead to arbitrary denials based on political views or personal expression. They emphasize the importance of opposing such legislation to protect fundamental freedoms.

Quick Summary

New York Senate Bill 9191 proposes requiring firearm license applicants to submit three years of social media history and one year of search engine data. Critics argue this bill infringes on Second and First Amendment rights, potentially leading to arbitrary denials based on online activity and setting a dangerous precedent for government surveillance.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Bill Overview
  2. 01:16Merchandise Promotion
  3. 02:13SB 9191 Details: Social Media & Search History
  4. 03:05Constitutional Infringement Arguments
  5. 06:24Specific Content Review Criteria
  6. 07:04Criticism of Bill's Constitutionality
  7. 08:00Slippery Slope Argument: Beyond Social Media
  8. 10:21Reading the Bill Text: Data Acquisition
  9. 11:19Specific Platforms and Search Engines Listed
  10. 11:33Power of Social Media & Censorship
  11. 13:32Government Interference with Free Speech
  12. 14:07State-Level Legislation Spreading Nationally
  13. 15:31Legislative Trends in Other States
  14. 16:01YouTube & PragerU Lawsuit Analogy
  15. 17:38Precedent for Government Control of Information
  16. 18:37Call to Action: Oppose SB 9191
  17. 19:01Political Climate & Anti-Gun Bills
  18. 19:36Urgency to Act & Avoid Complacency
  19. 20:03Support & Thank You to Viewers

Frequently Asked Questions

What is New York Senate Bill 9191?

New York Senate Bill 9191 is proposed legislation that would require individuals applying for a license to carry or possess a firearm to submit three years of their social media history and one year of their search engine history for review by law enforcement.

What kind of information would be reviewed under SB 9191?

Under SB 9191, law enforcement would review social media posts and search engine queries for content including profane slurs, biased language related to protected characteristics, threats to safety, or any indication of terrorism. This review would cover specific platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and Google.

What are the main concerns regarding New York SB 9191?

Critics argue that SB 9191 infringes upon fundamental constitutional rights, specifically the Second Amendment right to bear arms and the First Amendment right to freedom of speech and privacy. There are also concerns about government overreach and the potential for arbitrary denial of licenses based on personal online activity.

How does SB 9191 relate to digital privacy?

SB 9191 directly impacts digital privacy by mandating the disclosure of personal social media accounts and search engine histories, including login credentials. This raises concerns about government surveillance and the precedent it sets for accessing private online data.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Iraqveteran8888

View all →