Gun Owners News Hour: Dave Kopel

Published on August 7, 2017
Duration: 38:36

This video explores the historical and theological underpinnings of self-defense and military action within the Judeo-Christian tradition, drawing heavily on David Kopel's book. It argues that the tradition supports the use of force to defend innocent lives and resist tyrannical government, tracing these ideas from the Old and New Testaments through Western political thought and the American Founding. The discussion highlights the moral justification for self-defense and the right of the people to alter or abolish governments that rule against the common good.

Quick Summary

The Judeo-Christian tradition generally supports the use of sufficient force to stop aggression and protect innocent lives. This includes the possibility of the aggressor's death if it's necessary to end the threat, a view rooted in both Old and New Testament teachings. The Bible's teaching on "resist not evil" is interpreted metaphorically, not as a prohibition against self-defense or resisting tyrannical government.

Chapters

  1. 00:10Introduction & David Kopel's Book
  2. 01:32Old Testament Basis for Force
  3. 03:06New Testament & Peter's Sword
  4. 06:46Jesus's Last Supper Instruction
  5. 08:04Sermon on the Mount Context
  6. 09:32Kopel's Book Recap
  7. 10:47Founding Fathers & Scripture
  8. 13:11Paul's Letter to Romans
  9. 13:34Christian Teaching on Tyranny
  10. 14:14Biblical Example of Tyranny
  11. 15:13Maimonides on Tyranny
  12. 16:08American Political Thought
  13. 17:30English Revolution & Stuarts
  14. 18:35Book Title & Western History
  15. 19:38Resistance in WWII Europe
  16. 20:31Justification of Resistance
  17. 21:08Allies' Plight of Jews
  18. 22:38Resistance Funding in Europe
  19. 23:01Jews in French Resistance
  20. 24:00Harry Truman & Israel
  21. 25:05Truman's Recognition of Israel
  22. 26:03Middle East Christian Minorities
  23. 27:03Holocaust & Disarmament
  24. 28:08Kopel's Definitive Work
  25. 29:10Religion in American Settlement
  26. 30:30American Revolution & Preachers
  27. 32:30Justification for Revolution
  28. 33:38Citizenship & Arms
  29. 35:37Ammunition Supply Pivotal
  30. 36:04Making Own Ammunition
  31. 36:3420th Century Complacency
  32. 39:00Conclusion & Book Recommendation

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Judeo-Christian tradition's stance on self-defense?

The Judeo-Christian tradition generally supports the use of sufficient force to stop aggression and protect innocent lives. This includes the possibility of the aggressor's death if it's necessary to end the threat, a view rooted in both Old and New Testament teachings.

How does the Bible address resisting evil?

The Bible, particularly Jesus's Sermon on the Mount, addresses "resist not evil" metaphorically, discouraging personal vengeance or insult. It does not prohibit resisting life-threatening attacks or tyrannical government, which are seen as distinct from personal affronts.

What is the historical basis for the right to resist tyrannical government?

Drawing from biblical examples and centuries of Christian thought, the right to resist tyrannical government is based on the principle that government derives its legitimacy from God and the people. When a government rules against the common good, the people have a duty to remove it.

Why was an armed populace important during the American Revolution?

An armed populace was crucial during the American Revolution as it allowed colonists to effectively resist British forces, as seen at Lexington and Concord. This demonstrated that a professional army could not easily subdue an armed citizenry, reinforcing the idea of citizens bearing arms.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Gun Owners of America

View all →