NEW Unanimous Decision On ATF National Gun Control!

Chapters

1. 00:00Introduction to HR8 and Senate Floor
2. 00:30Unanimous Decision on ATF National Gun Control
3. 00:42Supreme Court Allows Biden Ghost Gun Regulation
4. 01:04Gun Owners Challenge ATF Rule
5. 01:43New York Law Bans Guns in Public Locations
6. 02:31Court Suspends Texas Federal Judge's Decision
7. 02:47ATF Regulations on Ghost Firearms
8. 03:20Requirements for Manufacturers and Sellers
9. 03:34Praise from Gun Control Organizations
10. 04:00ATF's Role in Making Law
11. 04:43Judge O'Connor's Ruling in Texas
12. 05:03Challengers' Arguments
13. 05:12Supreme Court's Potential Review
14. 05:37Solicitor General's Argument
15. 06:01Gun Control Act of 1968
16. 06:19Fifth US Circuit Court of Appeals
17. 06:43Offenses and Mandatory Minimums
18. 06:53Criminalizing Law-Abiding Citizens
19. 07:08ATF Regulation Change
20. 07:27Justice Samuel Alito's Temporary Hold
21. 07:36Supreme Court's Support for Gun Rights
22. 08:00Upcoming Supreme Court Term
23. 08:16Ghost Firearms Legal Question
24. 08:31Call for Change
25. 08:49Bumpfire Stock Explanation
26. 09:14Focus on Sensitive Places
27. 09:21Texas Attorney General's Tweet
28. 09:32Supreme Court Allows ATF to Enforce Ghost Gun Rules
29. 09:53Supreme Court Vote Count
30. 10:05Justice Samuel Alito's Temporary Pause
31. 10:08Justices Dissenting on Biden Administration Request
32. 10:16Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Barrett's Stance
33. 10:35White House Satisfaction with Decision
34. 10:46Combating Surge of Unserialized Ghost Guns
35. 11:06Legal Battle Reaches Supreme Court
36. 11:13Regulation Targeting Ghost Guns
37. 11:28ATF Action in August 2022
38. 11:37Definition of Firearm Modified
39. 11:43Background Checks for Young People
40. 12:00Disputes Settled with Guns
41. 12:08Brace Exempt from Rule
42. 12:13Conventional Wisdom on Republican Support
43. 12:29Mandatory Minimums
44. 12:31Combating Prevalence of Ghost Guns
45. 12:41Definition of Frames or Receivers
46. 12:53Legal Battle Over Ghost Guns
47. 13:11Rule Does Not Prohibit Ownership
48. 13:22Individual Creating Firearm at Home
49. 13:26Coalition Opposes ATF Limits
50. 13:40Violation of the Law
51. 13:43Federal District Judge Stops Challenge Terms
52. 13:54Heightened Need for Self-Defense
53. 14:04Walking Out with Rifle or Shotgun
54. 14:08Seeking Asylum in Other Countries
55. 14:19Summary of What Law is Doing
56. 14:26Blind Loyalty to Speaker Dave Felen
57. 14:32President's Veto
58. 14:39Brace Has Changed
59. 14:42July 5th Regulation Declared Unconstitutional
60. 14:52Judge Reed O'Connor Sided with Petitioners
61. 15:01Biden Administration Petition to Fifth Circuit
62. 15:11Court of Appeals Decided Not to Stay Ruling
63. 15:16Fifth Circuit Fast-Tracks Appeal
64. 15:22Government Contention on State Grant
65. 15:39Petitioned Supreme Court to Halt Order
66. 15:44District Court's Universal Veto
67. 15:55Untraceable Ghost Guns Flowing into Communities
68. 15:58Solicitor General Elizabeth Progger's Statement
69. 16:05Damage Already Done
70. 16:13Inevitably Used in Crimes
71. 16:17Plaintiffs Contended ATF Exceeded Power
72. 16:27Redefining Frame or Receiver and Firearm
73. 16:30Run for Office on Gun Violence
74. 16:35AK-47 Explained
75. 16:39Prevent the Next Tragedy
76. 16:48Doesn't Fit the Definition
77. 16:53ATF Audit
78. 17:01Banning of a Piece of Plastic
79. 17:03ATF Agreed to in 2012
80. 17:08Not Under Jurisdiction of Your Rule
81. 17:13Keep Them Separate
82. 17:16Brace Technology for Pistols
83. 17:18ATF Does Not Want Rifle Sight on Pistol
84. 17:23Foam Cover Over Buffer
85. 17:29Don't Want You to Shoulder It
86. 17:33One or Two Inch Eye Relief
87. 17:36Plaintiffs Launched the Lawsuit
88. 17:40Testimony of Gun Owners and Dealers
89. 17:42ATF Making Moves to Overturn Policy
90. 17:51Goods That Aid Manufacturing of Weapons
91. 17:56Weapons by Private Persons
92. 18:01Modify Decisions Made by Congress
93. 18:04Congress Not the ATF Responsible
94. 18:12Morehouse Versus ATF Legal Battles
95. 18:17Lawsuit Against New Frame and Receiver Requirements
96. 18:28ATF's New Frame and Receiver Requirements
97. 18:31More People Carrying Handguns
98. 18:37Parents, Relatives, Victims
99. 18:43Exercise Authority Unconstitutionally
100. 18:47Student Loans
101. 18:49Buy Hundreds of Guns Legally
102. 18:538th Circuit Court of Appeals Decision
103. 18:56Not Favorable
104. 19:01Panel of Three Judges
105. 19:08Waiting with Baited Breath
106. 19:12Decision Handed Down by 8th Circuit
107. 19:15Gun Owners of America Goa
108. 19:19Persuade 8th Circuit
109. 19:22Rule Violates Second Amendment
110. 19:26Case Supported by Assertion
111. 19:28Administrative Procedures Act
112. 19:31Second Amendment and Other Protections
113. 19:35States Joined This Case
114. 20:05North Carolina Included
115. 20:128th Circuit Court of Appeals Contrast
116. 20:14Conclusion Unanimously
117. 20:16Preliminary Injunction Should Not Be Issued
118. 20:18June of 2021
119. 20:21Changed Department's Asylum Rules
120. 20:25Individuals with Significant Gain Violence
121. 20:29Harmed Other People
122. 20:33Defense of the Second Amendment
123. 20:34Missouri Law Exposes People to Greater Harm
124. 20:39Federal Government's Ability to Enforce Regulations
125. 20:46Shooting from an Elevated Position
126. 20:49Plunging Fire
127. 20:54Ruling Made Because Plaintiffs Provided Evidence
128. 21:00ATF Caused Damage
129. 21:03Damage Couldn't Be Repaired
130. 21:05Significance of Firearms as Frames and Receivers
131. 21:07Not the Same as Firearms Themselves
132. 21:09Lawsuit Directed Against ATF
133. 21:15Frames and Receivers Requirement
134. 21:19New Regulation from ATF
135. 21:22Sale of Products Restricted
136. 21:2780 Centers Subject to Restrictions
137. 21:31Control Weapons Fully Made
138. 21:33Unfavorable Judgment Handed Down
139. 21:368th Circuit Court of Appeals
140. 21:40Lawsuit Brought Against ATF by Morouse
141. 21:43Extraordinary Courage
142. 21:48Anti-Gunners Put In There
143. 21:50Keep Guns Out of Hands of Lawful Citizens
144. 21:53New York State
145. 21:54No Difference to This Guy
146. 21:56Straight Up This Guy Was Evil
147. 21:58Committed Murder
148. 22:02Affect Us Here
149. 22:06Breath of Fresh Air
150. 22:08Second Amendment People
151. 22:10Case Challenged ATF's New Frame and Receiver Restrictions
152. 22:13In Spite of Restrictions
153. 22:15Goa and Coalition of 17 States
154. 22:20Preliminary Injunctions Not Justified
155. 22:22Reasons for This Decision
156. 22:25Inability to Prove Irreparable Injury
157. 22:27Frames and Receivers Fundamentally Different
158. 22:31Full Guns
159. 22:34Case Sheds Light on Discussions
160. 22:36Weapons Regulations
161. 22:39Constitutional Rights
162. 22:42Inventing the Pistol Stabilizing Brace
163. 22:45Disabled Combat Veteran
164. 22:48Testimony of Brave ATF Agents
165. 22:50Showing Up at 2 in the Morning
166. 22:52After a Burglary
167. 22:54Colleagues on Other Side of Aisle
168. 22:56Separation of Powers
169. 22:58Connecticut Delegation
170. 23:00Incredible Delegation
171. 23:02Best Delegation in United States
172. 23:04No Guns Were Lost
173. 23:06Stolen by an Individual
174. 23:09Criticism Over This
175. 23:11Why Is It Not a Machine Gun
176. 23:14Areas That Are Poor
177. 23:17Mostly Minority
178. 23:17Mass Shooting
179. 23:20Congress Wants to Change the Law
180. 23:22New Interpretation
181. 23:25ATF Will Follow That Interpretation
182. 23:27Impact of New ATF Rule
183. 23:30Legal Challenges
184. 23:32Complex Regulatory Structure
185. 23:36Important Legal Debate
186. 23:39ATF's Amended Definition of Firearm
187. 23:42Metamorphosis
188. 23:45Complicated Network of References
189. 23:4880 Centers Under Scope of Weapons
190. 23:50Modification
191. 23:52Serialization and Background Checks
192. 23:56Unfinished Firearm Component
193. 23:59Conversation Taken to New Level
194. 24:01ATF Published Open Letter
195. 24:06Freestanding Unfinished Polymer Frames
196. 24:08Regulations Limits
197. 24:10Absence of Supporting Equipment
198. 24:13Jigs, Drill Bits, or Instructions
199. 24:15Rule Applies to All Unfinished Polymer Frames
200. 24:20Previous Declarations Issued by ATF
201. 24:29Vanderdoog Case
202. 24:34Texas Federal District Court
203. 24:38Fifth Circuit
204. 24:40New Statement
205. 24:43Other 9-year-olds Killed in Shooting
206. 24:48Horrific
207. 24:50Seven Cycles of Fire
208. 25:00Federal Agent on Ground
209. 25:06Background Checks
210. 25:08Stop Illegal Guns
211. 25:12Shall Not Be Infringed
212. 25:14Banning Parts on Firearms
213. 25:16Against the Constitution
214. 25:18Background Information Essential
215. 25:20Ruling Handed Down by 8th Circuit
216. 25:22Morouse Case
217. 25:27Final Rule
218. 25:29Amended Definition of Firearm
219. 25:32Most Important Aspect
220. 25:34Regulation Challenged
221. 25:36Morouse Litigation
222. 25:38District Court in North Dakota
223. 25:40Supported by 17 Other States
224. 25:43Request to Seek Preliminary Injunction
225. 25:46Prevent ATF from Enforcing New Rule
226. 25:50Extensive Investigation
227. 25:52Judge Peter Wilts
228. 25:55Injunction Was Not Required
229. 25:57Present State of Affairs
230. 25:59Evidence of ATF's Response
231. 26:01Second Amendment
232. 26:03Notice and Comment Period
233. 26:05Proposed Rule Making
234. 26:08Adequate
235. 26:09Misinterpretations by the ATF
236. 26:11Future
237. 26:14Reason Why Somebody Might Want to SBR
238. 26:16Apply for That
239. 26:17Make This Legal
240. 26:19Apply for the Tax Stamp
241. 26:2210-inch AR-15 Pistol
242. 26:25Pistol Brace
243. 26:25Considered an SBR
244. 26:29Multiple Pistols
245. 26:34Apply for the Tax Stamp
246. 26:36Not Pay the $200 Fee
247. 26:39Pro Second Amendment
248. 26:40Take Your Second Amendment Rights Away
249. 26:43Sensitive Places Doctrine
250. 26:45Not an Issue in This Case
251. 26:49Looks Forward to Quick Resolution
252. 26:52Texas Senate
253. 26:54Pull the Gun Into My Trigger Finger
254. 27:01Prepared and Carry a Gun
255. 27:03Split Second Decisions
256. 27:05Not Exempt from Your Rule
257. 27:08Classify This as the Brace
258. 27:10Wrote The Letter
259. 27:12Determined That ATF's Position
260. 27:14Proposed Regulation Harmonized
261. 27:16Second Amendment Jurisprudence
262. 27:18Crafted Was Correct
263. 27:21Difficult for ATF to Anticipate Future Developments
264. 27:25Specifically Referring to ATF's Answer
265. 27:29Supreme Court Ruling in Bruen Case
266. 27:34Judge Made Effort to Lessen Significance
267. 27:35Bruin Judgment
268. 27:39Troubling Aspect of Ruling
269. 27:42Limiting Bruin's Implications
270. 27:44Proper Cause Standards
271. 27:46Concealed Carry Legislation
272. 27:49Compartmentalize Landmark Decision
273. 27:51Supreme Court
274. 27:53More Limited Context
275. 27:56Dismissing Rulings Possible Repercussions
276. 28:00Second Amendment
277. 28:02Legal Environment Around New Rule
278. 28:04Fraught with Difficulties
279. 28:07Goa and Coalition of States Challenged Rule
280. 28:10Court's Ruling Regarding Preliminary Injunction
281. 28:12Favorable to the ATF
282. 28:19Variety of Factors
283. 28:21Responses Provided by ATF
284. 28:23Rule Making Process
285. 28:26Changing Nature of Legal Landscape
286. 28:28Significance of Bruin Judgment
287. 28:33Dynamic Field of Conflict
288. 28:34Weapons Restrictions
289. 28:37Judicial Interpretation
290. 28:39Legal Battles Still Being Fought Out
291. 28:44Doesn't Care About Separation of Powers
292. 28:46Texas House of Representatives
293. 28:48Impeach Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton
294. 28:53How Many Guns Has ATF Lost
295. 28:58Not Sure I Understand the Question
296. 29:00It Will Shoot Then It Comes Back Forward
297. 29:02Rifle Will Then Cycle
298. 29:06Extent to Which This is Unconstitutional Violation
299. 29:08Second Amendment Rights
300. 29:16Incumbent Upon United States Congress
301. 29:19House of Representatives
302. 29:23Missouri Law Exposes People to Greater Harm
303. 29:26Interfering with Federal Government's Ability
304. 29:27Enforce Firearms Regulations
305. 29:29Legal Challenges Persist
306. 29:328th Circuits Verdict on ATF's Receiver Rule
307. 29:34Challenge Over Carry Permit
308. 29:37Different Direction
309. 29:39Preliminary Injunction Turned Down
310. 29:42Gun Owners of America Goa
311. 29:45Group That Ultimately Brought the Case
312. 29:478th Circuit Court of Appeals
313. 29:51Carrying the Mantle of Contestation
314. 29:53Legal Ladder
315. 29:56Judge Steven Colton Presided
316. 29:58Panel That Investigated the Case
317. 30:00Careful Consideration
318. 30:02Three Judges Came to Conclusion
319. 30:04Decision Made by Lower Court
320. 30:06Not Grant the Injunction Was Reasonable
321. 30:08Supported by Sufficient Evidence
322. 30:11Direct Consequence
323. 30:11ATF's Receiver's Rule
324. 30:13Will Not Be Put on Hold
325. 30:16Determined by Their Decision
326. 30:188th Circuit Gave Careful Consideration
327. 30:20Michael Malloy and Raymond Grunder's Oral Arguments
328. 30:24Delivered Before the Court
329. 30:27Idea That Plaintiffs Were Unable to Provide Sufficient Evidence
330. 30:29Support Possibility of Irreparable Injury
331. 30:31Result of ATF's Regulation
332. 30:33Basis for Majority of Their Conclusion
333. 30:38Obtain a Preliminary Injunction
334. 30:40Party Must Demonstrate
335. 30:42Likely to Suffer Irreparable Harm
336. 30:45Absence of Injunctive Relief
337. 30:47Balance of Equities
338. 30:49Tilting in Their Favor
339. 30:51Obtaining an Injunction Is in Best Interest
340. 30:53General Public
341. 30:56Position of the Court Was Made Clear
342. 30:58Statement
343. 31:00We Find That Plaintiffs Have Failed to Demonstrate
344. 31:02Will Suffer Irreparable Injury
345. 31:04Absence of a Temporary Injunction
346. 31:07Need Not Evaluate Likelihood of Success on Merit
347. 31:098th Circuit Court of Appeals Came to This Conclusion
348. 31:12Unable to Identify Irretrievable Losses
349. 31:14Goa and Coalition of 17 States
350. 31:16Especially True in a Circumstance
351. 31:19Legitimacy of These Arguments
352. 31:22Being Investigated by Other Parties
353. 31:29Ruling of 8th Circuit Court of Appeals
354. 31:30Brought to Light Intriguing Tactical Component
355. 31:34Pretty Clear About Extent
356. 31:37Abuse of Administrative Procedures Act
357. 31:38Difficult Question to Understand
358. 31:44Enormously High
359. 31:4736 Per 100,000 People
360. 31:50Little Bit of Motion
361. 31:52Hear the Click
362. 31:54Felt I Needed to Be Able to Protect Myself
363. 32:02In Light of Fact That Fifth Circuit
364. 32:04Examine ATF Rule on Frames and Receivers
365. 32:06Vanderstock Case
366. 32:088th Circuit Appeared to Carefully Dodge
367. 32:11Considering Likelihood of Success on Merit
368. 32:13Essential Component in Consideration of Injunction
369. 32:15Ruling of 8th Circuit Court of Appeals
370. 32:17Didn't Address This Facet of Issue
371. 32:19Appeared to Delay the Matter
372. 32:21Action That Some People May View
373. 32:23Tactical Maneuver
374. 32:26Decision Reached by 8th Circuit Court of Appeals
375. 32:28Something of a Punt
376. 32:30Strategic Standpoint
377. 32:32Word Embodies Idea
378. 32:34Court Chose Not to Fully Engage
379. 32:36Critical Component of the Case
380. 32:39Potentially Because of Anticipated Review
381. 32:41Same ATF Rule by Fifth Circuit
382. 32:45Review Expected to Take Place
383. 32:47Near Future
384. 32:50Ongoing Legal Battle Continues
385. 32:55Topic of Conversation
386. 32:57Intricate and Dynamic
387. 32:59Complexities of Legal Strategy
388. 33:02Ramifications of Decisions Made
389. 33:04Appellant Court
390. 33:06Dynamics of Continuous Litigation
391. 33:08Actually Make Laws Without Congressional Approval
392. 33:11They're Really There to Enforce Laws
393. 33:14Blatantly Denying Power Grab
394. 33:15Carried Out by Executive Branch
395. 33:19Yet Again
396. 33:21Uptick in Violence
397. 33:23Astronomical
398. 33:26Gun Violence
399. 33:28Came Out of Different Movement
400. 33:31Civil Rights Movement
401. 33:33Felt Good About Doing This Kind of Event
402. 33:34Felt Empowered
403. 33:378th Circuits Emphasis on Irreparable Harm
404. 33:40Strategic Deferral
405. 33:43Complex Web of Legal Proceedings
406. 33:458th Circuit Court of Appeals Focused Its Consideration
407. 33:47Idea of Irreparable Harm
408. 33:50Morouse Case
409. 33:51Decision to Postpone the Matter
410. 33:53Fifth Circuit
411. 33:56Deliberate Determination to Pass On Responsibility
412. 33:57Judging Likelihood of Success on Merits
413. 33:59Central Tenant of Their Reasoning
414. 34:01Court Is of the Conclusion
415. 34:04Plaintiff's Assertion
416. 34:06May Suffer Harm to Their Rights
417. 34:08Second Amendment
418. 34:10Event That Preliminary Injunction Isn't Granted
419. 34:13ATF Agreed to in 2012
420. 34:17Should Not Be Under Jurisdiction of Your Rule
421. 34:18Conventional Wisdom
422. 34:20Never Get Any Republicans to Support Gun Legislation
423. 34:23Period
424. 34:31ATF Decided to Change a Regulation
425. 34:35Interpretation of the Regulation
426. 34:36May Just Want to Spr Right Off the Bat
427. 34:38Do Anything About What the President Is Doing
428. 34:40Exercise That Authority Unconstitutionally
429. 34:42Case with Student Loans
430. 34:44On the Other Hand
431. 34:46Court Considers This Allegation
432. 34:48Risk of Irreparable Damage
433. 34:51Plaintiffs Didn't Provide Sufficient Evidence
434. 34:53Support Their Claim
435. 34:55Irreparable Injury Is Likely to Arise
436. 34:57Absence of an Injunction
437. 35:00Essential to Recognize
438. 35:02Result Reached by the Court
439. 35:04Early Stage of the Case
440. 35:07Doesn't in Any Way Prejudge
441. 35:09Validity of the Claim
442. 35:11Second Amendment
443. 35:11Position Taken by the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals
444. 35:13May or May Not Reflect Their Current Judgment
445. 35:15Absence of Immediate Constitutional Harm
446. 35:18Doesn't Mean Plaintiffs Will Not Be Successful
447. 35:20Gun Owners of America
448. 35:2217 States
449. 35:24Claims Based on Second Amendment
450. 35:26Problem Appears to Be Purposely Punted Back
451. 35:29Lower Court
452. 35:31Indicate a Reluctance
453. 35:33Part of the Court to Give a Decisive Judgment
454. 35:36Lack of Potential for Irreparable Injury
455. 35:38Further Notes
456. 35:40Will Not Address Other Considerations
457. 35:42Necessary for Preliminary Injunction
458. 35:46Chance of Winning on the Merit
459. 35:48Very Heart Of This Legal Battle
460. 35:50Consideration That 8th Circuit Court of Appeals Wants to Defer On
461. 35:57Later Date
462. 35:59Conviction That There Wasn't Absence of Irreparable Injury
463. 36:02Driving Force Behind Their Decision
464. 36:03Dismiss or Deny the Request for an Injunction
465. 36:08Crime for Someone Already Convicted of Felony
466. 36:10Possess Any Firearm
467. 36:13Implemented by States
468. 36:16My Administration Is Going to Focus On
469. 36:18How They Administer
470. 36:20Violate Other Laws
471. 36:22Saying You Can Bring a Gun In Here
472. 36:25Can't Go Into With a Gun
473. 36:25Mr Henderson Turned Over His Firearms
474. 36:27FBI Before He Was Convicted
475. 36:30Gun Owners Wanted Supreme Court to Put Statute on Hold
476. 36:34Have Now Said No
477. 36:37This Morning Though
478. 36:40Critical Issue Gun Violence Restrictions
479. 36:42New York Passed on Their Statute
480. 36:44Where You Can Have Guns
481. 36:46Places That Don't Have a Sign
482. 36:49Condition of Gaining Bail Before Trial
483. 36:52Government Has Kept Possession of Firearms
484. 36:54Sign a Law
485. 36:57Bipartisan Safety Legis Gun Safety Legislation
486. 36:59Those Laws Will Still Be in Effect
487. 37:02Until First Court of Appeals Hears It
488. 37:05New York
489. 37:07Government to Transfer Those Firearms
490. 37:10Which He Doesn't Possess Himself
491. 37:12Families Who Were Victimized