New York. Introducing America's Dumbest Gun Law Yet.

Published on February 19, 2023
Duration: 6:57

This analysis dissects New York's Assembly Bill 4271, a proposed law that aims to ban the sale of 'child operated firearms' by FFLs. The bill defines such firearms as pistols or revolvers manufactured 12+ months after the law's effective date that lack specific child-proofing mechanisms, such as a 10-pound trigger pull or designs preventing operation by a five-year-old. The expert critique highlights the law's flawed premise, questioning the focus on child misuse and the impracticality of proposed safety features for self-defense. The video also contextualizes this bill within New York's broader trend of restrictive gun legislation.

Quick Summary

New York Assembly Bill 4271 proposes banning FFLs from selling 'child operated firearms,' defined as pistols/revolvers made 12+ months after enactment lacking child-proofing. This includes a 10-pound trigger pull or mechanisms inoperable by a five-year-old. Violations are a Class A misdemeanor, but the law faces criticism for its flawed premise and impracticality for self-defense.

Chapters

  1. 00:07State Gun Law Competition
  2. 00:43NY's Dumbest Gun Law Proposal: AB 4271
  3. 00:57Bill 4271 Details: Child Operated Firearms
  4. 01:39Defining 'Child Operated Firearm'
  5. 02:50Child-Proofing Requirements Explained
  6. 04:16State Police Role in Standards
  7. 04:44Penalties for Violation
  8. 04:51Critique of the Law's Logic
  9. 05:49Context: NY Gun Laws
  10. 06:03Conclusion: AB 4271

Frequently Asked Questions

What is New York Assembly Bill 4271?

Assembly Bill 4271 is a proposed New York law that aims to ban Federal Firearm Licensees (FFLs) from selling firearms defined as 'child operated.' This definition applies to pistols and revolvers manufactured 12 months or more after the law's effective date that lack specific child-proofing features.

How does NY AB 4271 define a 'child operated firearm'?

Under AB 4271, a 'child operated firearm' is a pistol or revolver made at least 12 months after the law takes effect, which does not have a child-proofing device. These devices include a trigger pull of at least 10 pounds or mechanisms designed to be too small for a five-year-old's hands to operate.

What are the penalties for violating proposed NY gun law AB 4271?

If enacted, violating New York Assembly Bill 4271 would result in a Class A misdemeanor. This classification indicates a serious offense under New York state law, carrying potential jail time and fines.

What are the main criticisms of New York's Assembly Bill 4271?

Critics argue the law is based on a flawed premise, as crime statistics do not show children shooting people as a major issue. Furthermore, the proposed child-proofing is considered illogical for being limited to age five and impractical for self-defense if it requires multiple steps to fire.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Washington Gun Law

View all →