NY GOVERNOR KATHY HOCHUL'S "GUN FREE ZONES" FAILURE AS NATIONAL GUARD DEPLOYED IN NYC

Published on March 7, 2024
Duration: 14:16

This video critically examines Governor Kathy Hochul's deployment of the National Guard to NYC subways as a response to crime, arguing it's ineffective 'security theater' and unconstitutional. Expert Mark Smith, a constitutional attorney, contends that mandated gun-free zones and 'sensitive place' designations, as implemented by Hochul, violate Second Amendment rights and fail to address the root causes of crime, which he attributes to policies releasing violent offenders. The discussion highlights the perceived disconnect between government actions and the protection of law-abiding citizens.

Quick Summary

New York Governor Kathy Hochul's deployment of the National Guard to NYC subways is criticized as 'security theater' and an unconstitutional failure of 'gun-free zone' policies. Constitutional attorney Mark Smith argues these measures infringe on Second Amendment rights and do not address the root causes of crime.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Hochul's Gun-Free Zones & National Guard Deployment
  2. 00:42Speaker Credentials: Mark Smith, Constitutional Attorney
  3. 00:54NYC Subway Security: Performance Art vs. Policy
  4. 01:50Ineffectiveness of Random Subway Searches
  5. 02:58Limited Coverage of Subway Security Checks
  6. 03:33Event Security vs. Subway Security Challenges
  7. 04:18Gun-Free Zones and Rising Crime Rates
  8. 05:54Governor Hochul's Motivations & Second Amendment Sentiment
  9. 06:33NYC Security Measures vs. Constitutional Rights
  10. 07:10Bruen Decision's 'Sensitive Places' and Subway Issues
  11. 08:07Requirements for Comprehensive Security
  12. 09:10Political Motivations and Government Expansion

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is the National Guard being deployed to NYC subways?

Governor Kathy Hochul has deployed the National Guard to NYC subways, citing a need for enhanced security. However, critics argue this is 'security theater' and an admission that her 'gun-free zone' policies have failed to deter crime.

Are New York's 'gun-free zones' constitutional?

Constitutional attorney Mark Smith argues that government-mandated gun-free zones and 'sensitive place' laws, like those implemented by Governor Hochul for NYC subways, are unconstitutional, citing the Supreme Court's Bruen decision.

What are the criticisms of the security measures in NYC subways?

Criticisms include that the measures are 'security theater,' ineffective due to random and limited searches, and that they infringe on Second Amendment rights without addressing the root causes of crime, such as the release of violent offenders.

What does the Bruen decision say about 'sensitive places'?

The Bruen decision identified legislative assemblies, courthouses, and polling places as historically recognized 'sensitive places' where firearm restrictions might be permissible. The application of this to public transit like subways is contested.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from The Four Boxes Diner

View all →