Supreme Court UNANIMOUS Decision To REMOVE 2A

Name: Supreme Court UNANIMOUS Decision To REMOVE 2A
Uploaded: 2024-01-31T19:15:01+00:00
Duration: 25 min 52 s
Channel: Best Iron

Best Iron

Published on January 31, 2024

Category: 2nd Amendment & Law

Duration: 25:52

This video details the Supreme Court's landmark decision in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruen, which struck down New York's 'proper cause' requirement for concealed carry permits. The ruling established that the Second Amendment protects an individual's right to carry firearms for self-defense in public, and that such laws must be consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. The decision has significant implications for gun control laws nationwide, prompting legal challenges and re-evaluation of existing regulations.

Quick Summary

The Supreme Court's decision in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruen declared New York's 'proper cause' requirement for concealed carry permits unconstitutional. This landmark ruling affirmed that the Second Amendment protects the right to carry firearms in public for self-defense and mandated that gun control laws must align with historical traditions of firearm regulation.

Chapters

00:00Introduction to Gun Control Debates
00:05Second Amendment Protections
00:14Bureaucratic Decisions and Felon Status
00:38New Mexico Governor's Actions
00:49Supreme Court Strikes Down NY Concealed Carry Law
01:11Significance of the Supreme Court Victory
01:22Calls for Universal Background Checks
01:29Largest Increase in Gun Rights
01:43New York Law's History
01:51Majority Opinion by Justice Clarence Thomas
02:03Dissenting Opinion
02:1714th Amendment and Equal Protection
02:27Recent Mass Shootings and Gun Debate
02:38Distinction from Automatic Weapons Ban
02:46Assault Weapons and AR-15s
02:51Political Reactions to the Decision
03:07President Biden's Call for Gun Laws
03:16Governor Kathy Hochul's Response
03:42Mayor Eric Adams' Statement
03:50Lawsuit Details: NYSRPA v. Bruen
04:04Uvaldi Parents' Plea
04:09Pistol Brace Functionality
04:15Justice Richard McNally's Decision
04:28Appeal to New York Federal Court
04:46Second Circuit Court of Appeals Ruling
04:54Supreme Court Takes the Case
04:56Thomas's Opinion on Proper Cause
05:08Constitutionality of Firearm Bans
05:10Domestic Violence Restraining Orders
05:23Bureaucrats and Felon Status Revisited
05:31Right to Defend One's Life
05:36Setting the Stage for Second Amendment Cases
05:44Justice Department's Appeal
05:50Landmark Ruling in Bruen
06:01Bruen Ruling and Justice Thomas
06:06Altering Legal Standards for Gun Control
06:11Historical Context for Gun Laws
06:18Rahimi Case and Unconstitutionality
06:25Fifth US Circuit Court of Appeals
06:34Rahimi's Petition to the Supreme Court
06:46Lower Courts Adapting to New Standards
06:49Awaiting Resolution of Firearm Restriction Cases
07:07Responsible Gun Owners' Support
07:10Enhanced Background Checks
07:12Red Flag Laws
07:14Justice Department's Expedited Process
07:24Historical Precedent for Disarming Threats
07:34Fifth Circuit's Ruling Misinterpretation
07:45Impact on Domestic Violence Restraining Orders
08:01Supreme Court's New Gun Right Standards
08:06Landmark Decision Expanding Gun Rights
08:11New Legal Standard by Justice Thomas
08:16Changing Legal Context for Gun Laws
08:22Banning Devices that Turn Legal Weapons into Machine Guns
08:28Gun Outnumbered, Outstaffed
08:31Responsible Gun Legislation
08:34Banning Assault Weapons
08:38Judges and Historical Tradition
08:47Courtrooms Coast to Coast
08:55Activity and Uncertainty Post-Bruen
09:02Joseph Bloker on Firearms Law
09:07Supreme Court's New Methodology
09:14Consistent with Historical Tradition
09:22Government Proof for Gun Measures
09:31Constitutionally Permissible Gun Regulations
09:35Thomas: Constitution Protects Individual Conduct
09:44Government Must Show Historical Keeping
09:58Illinois Assault Weapons Ban
10:08Overturning New York Handgun Law
10:13Governors Enact New Firearm Restrictions
10:17Second Amendment and Common Use
10:24Ban All Weapons
10:30Lawsuits from Gun Rights Groups
10:36Bruen Judgment and New Regulations
10:40Navigating the New Legal Environment
10:45Federal Judges' Rulings
10:49Preventing Enforcement of Gun Laws
10:52Politics as Barrier to Gun Legislation
11:05Judges Overturning Gun Restrictions
11:07Courts Playing a More Active Role
11:10Room for Sensible Gun Laws
11:15Majority of Americans Support Gun Laws
11:16New York's New Regulations
11:24Concealed Carry Firearms Applicants
11:29Sensitive Areas for Firearms Use
11:39NYSRPA and Gun Owners Challenge Law
11:45Bruen Judgment Guidelines
11:49Federal District Court in Syracuse
11:56Second Circuit Upholds Regulations
11:58Firearm Owners' Requirements
12:04Supreme Court Urged to Step In
12:14Law Enforcement While Case Pending
12:16New York's Prohibitions
12:19Sensitive Locations
12:28New Jersey Law
12:31Legal Challenges by Gun Owners
12:36Sensitive Place Regulations Halted
12:43Regulating Second Amendment Conduct
12:47Historical Tradition of Firearm Regulation
12:52US District Judge Renee Bombadier
13:04Supreme Court's New Legal Standard
13:06Threatens Federal Statutes
13:10Legal Disputes in New Jersey and New York
13:17New Legislation in Reaction to Ruling
13:20Legal Challenges and Uncertainty
13:22US District Judge Joseph Goodwin
13:25West Virginia Man Case
13:31Handgun with Destroyed Serial Number
13:33Legislation Declared Unconstitutional
13:36Firearm Without Serial Number in 1791
13:49Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals Panel
13:53Bruen Ruling Impact
13:56Federal Law and Domestic Violence
14:04Unconstitutional Restriction
14:06Judge Corey Wilson's Statement
14:09Government Fails to Establish Historical Tradition
14:15Nation's Historical Tradition
14:18Law as an Outlier
14:20Quoting Thomas's Viewpoint
14:23Justice Department's Plan to Appeal
14:28Attorney General Merrick Garland
14:30Requesting a New Hearing
14:32Petitioning the Supreme Court
14:37Joseph Bloker on Domestic Abuse Firearms Law
14:40Restrictions Seen as Valid and Essential
14:47Disarming for Intimate Partner Violence
14:53Founding Era Legislators
14:57Ludicrous to Claim We Can't Do It Now
15:03Women's Legal Protection
15:06Bipartisan Support for Gun Control
15:08Red Flag Laws
15:10Temporary Orders for Firearm Seizure
15:15People Deemed a Threat
15:19Bruen Decision and Legal Challenges
15:23Public Health Order in New Mexico
15:25Taking Aim at Gun Violence
15:29Leading Cause of Death for Children
15:33Esther Sanchez Gomez
15:37District Court Judges' Difficulty Applying Bruen
15:40Weapon Regulation Consistency
15:44Country's Historical History
15:47Invites District Courts to Become Historians
15:54Laborious Operation for Professionals
16:04Busy Dockets
16:09US District Judge Carlton Reed
16:12Appointing a Historian
16:16Challenging Federal Law
16:19Prohibiting Felons from Possessing Firearms
16:23Historian Tradition Test
16:30Court Lacks Historical Training
16:35Supreme Court Justices Lack Formal Training
16:37Intellectual and Methodological Expertise
16:45Evidence Examination Methods
16:47Historians' Research Methods
16:52Perspectives of White Landowners
17:00Constitutional Adjudication
17:03Required to Play Historian
17:05Court Battles Over Gun Regulations
17:09Halt Enforcement of Laws
17:12Cases Being Heard
17:16State and Federal Efforts
17:18Difficulties Applying Legal Standard
17:22Recent Rulings Rejecting Laws
17:27Advocates for Gun Control
17:30Politicians Not Deterred by Court Disputes
17:34Sanchez Gomez's Advice
17:37Legislators Should Take Justice Thomas's Word
17:41Bruen Isn't a Regulatory Jacket
17:44Negotiating with Yourself
17:46Cost of Many Lives
17:49Doing Nothing in Wake of Violence
17:51Fear of Legal Challenges
17:53Discuss Bruen to Comprehend
17:57Developing Legal Standard
17:59Counterproductive Actions
18:01New Mexico Governor's Temporary Ban
18:03Public Firearms Carry Amid Gun Violence
18:06String of Gun Demises
18:0811-Year-Old Boy Slain
18:10Governor Michelle Luhan Grisham
18:14Historic Executive Order
18:16Temporary Banning of Firearms Carry
18:18Albuquerque and Surrounding Suburbs
18:20Openly or Concealed
18:24Effective for 30 Days
18:33People Will Disagree
18:35Invoke Additional Powers
18:38No Constitutional Right Infringed
18:41Republicans Criticize Measure
18:43Law Enforcement Warnings
18:47May Not Be Enforceable
18:50Order's Legality and Enforceability
18:52Roadblocks Encountered
18:54Beralo County Sheriff John Allen
18:56Challenges Foundation of Constitution
18:58Albuquerque Police Chief Harold Medina
19:03Police Department Not Responsible
19:08Outcry Pounced by Republican Officials
19:10Florida Governor Ron DeSantis
19:132024 Presidential Candidate
19:16Second Amendment Rights Shall Not Be Infringed
19:20Social Media Platform X
19:23Representative Lauren Boebert
19:26Prohibition Called Flawed
19:28Governor Declaring Emergency
19:30Right Before an Election
19:32Suspend the 19th Amendment
19:35Stop Women from Voting
19:37Open and Concealed Carry Prohibited
19:39Public Property for 30 Days
19:42Exceptions for Security Guards
19:44Law Enforcement Officers
19:47Public Health Order
19:51Went into Effect Immediately
19:54Fines of Up to $5,000
19:55Open Carry Illegal in Five States
19:58California, Florida, Illinois, New Jersey, New York
20:04Legal in Connecticut, Hawaii, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Rhode Island, South Carolina
20:10With a Permit
20:13Prospective Court Case
20:16Anticipates Legal Challenge
20:18Unsure of Legitimacy
20:21Utmost Recent Effort to Reduce Gun Violence
20:28Enforcement Related Concerns
20:30Rural Sheriffs Opposed Legislation
20:35Violated Constitutional Rights
20:36Due Process
20:39Right to Bear Arms
20:41Red Flag Law Signed in 2020
20:44State Courts Seize Firearms
20:46Dangerous to Themselves or Others
20:51Luhan Grisham's Request
20:53Law Enforcement Official Resignation
20:57Big Number 493
21:02Gun Violence Archives Data
21:04Mass Shootings
21:06Four or More People Slain or Injured
21:11Mass Shootings in the US This Year
21:13Gun Violence Archives
21:15Over 520 Persons Slain
21:18Everytown for Gun Safety Data
21:21Gun Demises per Year in New Mexico
21:2918.3 Demises per 100,000 Residents
21:33Land of Enchantment
21:358th Highest State for Gun Demises
21:392017 to 2021 Data
21:42143 Children Killed by Guns
21:47Committed to Working Together
21:531,000 or More Violent Crimes per 100,000
21:58Luhan Grisham's Executive Order
22:01Rate of Gun Demises Increased by 43%
22:032009 to 2018
22:08Larger Increase Than Nationwide
22:1018% Increase Nationwide
22:16Bipartisan Safer Communities Act
22:18President Joe Biden Signed Law
22:21Strengthened Gun Control Measures
22:23Closing the Boyfriend Loophole
22:25Domestic Abusers Owning Guns
22:30Gun Trafficking a Federal Crime
22:32Democratic Lawmakers Pushing Bills
22:35Reduce Gun Violence
22:39President Joe Biden Executive Order
22:42Tighten Background Checks
22:44Gun Dealers
22:49Federal Organizations Create Plans
22:52Stop Gun Dealers with Suspended Licenses
22:56Selling Weapons
22:59Democratic Initiatives Fall Short
23:02Vehement Opposition from GOP Members
23:06House Controlled by Democrats
23:08Bill to Outlaw Assault Weapons
23:11Failed in the Senate
23:13Strong Opposition from Republicans
23:15Violate Second Amendment Rights
23:19Curb Gun Violence
23:21Right Have Advocated for Legislation
23:23Mental Health and School Security
23:28House Speaker Kevin McCarthy
23:31Deal with Mental Illness
23:33Controversial Gun Rights Restriction
23:35New Mexico Sparks Outrage
23:39Governor Michelle Luhan Grisham's Decision
23:41Temporarily Ban Concealed and Open Carry
23:44City of Albuquerque and Bernalillo County
23:48Ignited Significant Controversy
23:51Criticism
23:54Governor as a Tyrant Wannabe
23:58Parallel to British Monarchy
24:01Infringes Upon Second Amendment Rights
24:05Concerning Precedent for the Future
24:09Supporters of Gun Rights
24:11Ban Enacted During Public Health Emergency
24:13Questionable Exercise of Power
24:16Further Encroachment on Individual Liberties
24:19During Crisis
24:22If Decision Goes Unchallenged
24:25Governors Emboldened to Take Similar Actions
24:27Event of Future Emergencies
24:32Return of COVID-19
24:34Response to the Ban
24:38Law Enforcement Officials Refused to Enforce
24:39Albuquerque Chief of Police Harold Medina
24:41Sheriff John Allen
24:44Violates Citizens' Core Constitutional Rights
24:46Chosen Not to Participate
24:54Likely Not to Agree
25:00Finley Acknowledged Fierce Opposition
25:02Law Enforcement Leaders
25:06Bunch of Resources to Utilize
25:08Making a Dent
25:10Critics of Governor's Actions
25:11Law Enforcement Agencies and Officers
25:14Consider Historical Context
25:16Implications of the Ban
25:18Essential for Law Enforcement
25:20Aware of Potential Consequences
25:23Supporting Restrictions
25:25Right to Bear Arms
25:27Conclusion
25:30Contentious Decision
25:32Sparked Passionate Debate
25:34Balance Between Public Safety and Individual Rights
25:36Times of Crisis
25:39Significant Concern and Discussion
25:41Citizens and Law Enforcement Agencies
25:44Affected Areas
25:46End of Video

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Supreme Court's decision in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruen?

The Supreme Court ruled that New York's 'proper cause' requirement for concealed carry permits was unconstitutional. This decision affirmed that the Second Amendment protects an individual's right to carry firearms in public for self-defense and that such laws must align with historical traditions of firearm regulation.

How did the Bruen decision change the legal standard for gun control laws?

The Bruen decision shifted the legal standard by requiring that gun control laws must be consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. This means governments can no longer simply assert a law promotes public safety; they must demonstrate historical precedent for the restriction.

What are the implications of the Bruen decision for other states?

The Bruen decision has significant implications for states with similar concealed carry restrictions. It has led to legal challenges against laws in at least eight other states and the District of Columbia, potentially invalidating many existing gun control measures that do not meet the historical tradition test.

Who wrote the majority opinion in the Bruen case, and what was the vote count?

The majority opinion in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruen was written by Justice Clarence Thomas. The Court ruled 6-3 in favor of the gun rights activists who challenged New York's law.

All Articles →

Gear Deep Dive22 min read

Common Use: The Math, the Law, and the 24 Million AR-15s in American Hands

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

He Banned Your Guns, Then Hired 150 Armed Officers to Protect Himself With $30 Million Tax Dollars

This video critiques Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson's stance on gun control, highlighting the perceived hypocrisy of him advocating for firearm bans while being protected by a large, armed security detail. It contrasts his views with those of other politicians and references legal precedents regarding the Second Amendment and the government's duty to protect citizens. The core argument is that politicians prioritize their own safety with firearms while restricting public access to them.

Brandon Johnson

Chicago Mayor

Channel:Colion Noir

Category:2nd Amendment & Law

Date: Apr 5, 2026

Duration: 6:13

West Virginia Just Gave 18-Year-Olds Their Gun Rights Back

West Virginia's HB4106, signed into law on April 1st, expands constitutional carry to include 18, 19, and 20-year-olds. This legislation clarifies that individuals aged 18-20, who are not otherwise prohibited from possessing a firearm, can now carry a concealed weapon without a permit, aligning with existing open carry laws for this age group. The law emphasizes that this right is for all law-abiding legal adults and aims to enhance self-defense capabilities.

West Virginia

HB4106

Channel:Colion Noir

Category:2nd Amendment & Law

Date: Apr 20, 2026

Duration: 6:07

Rejected: Two Major Gun Cases Denied By Supreme Court

The Supreme Court denied review for two significant Second Amendment cases: Peterson v. United States, concerning the NFA's taxation and registration of suppressors, and Gardner v. Maryland, which addressed firearm reciprocity across state lines. Several other major 2A cases were deferred to future conferences, extending the uncertainty for gun rights.

Supreme Court

Second Amendment

Channel:Copper Jacket TV

Category:2nd Amendment & Law

Date: Apr 20, 2026

Duration: 7:47

Is the $0 Tax for NFA Guns & Suppressors Working?

The video analyzes the impact of the $0 tax on NFA items, arguing it has significantly increased ownership and bolstered the 'common use' argument. This surge in NFA item registration is presented as a strategic move to challenge existing regulations in court, potentially leading to the end of the NFA.

NFA

ATF

Channel:The VSO Gun Channel

Category:2nd Amendment & Law

Date: Apr 20, 2026

Duration: 11:44

Frame and Receiver Rewrite BACK ON

The video discusses the ATF's fluctuating stance on rewriting the frame and receiver rule. Initially planning to rewrite, then stating they would keep the rule, the ATF has now announced plans to rewrite it again due to pressure from Second Amendment groups, industry stakeholders, and government officials. The new rule is expected to distinguish between metal and polymer components, potentially impacting hobbyists and small businesses by requiring FFL transfers for previously unregulated parts.

ATF

DOJ

Channel:Liberty Doll

Category:2nd Amendment & Law

Date: Apr 17, 2026

Duration: 3:54

Do Realize What Just Happened..? #shortsfeed #langley #congress #shortsvideo

This video discusses Justice Clarence Thomas's speech identifying progressivism as a direct threat to the US Constitution. The speaker argues that progressive ideals attempt to circumvent constitutional protections, particularly regarding gun rights, citing the Heller and Bruen decisions as examples of the Supreme Court upholding individual rights against such attempts. The content emphasizes the significance of this judicial stance in defending fundamental freedoms.

Second Amendment

Progressivism

Channel:Langley Outdoors Academy

Category:2nd Amendment & Law

Date: Apr 17, 2026

Duration: 2:57

More from Best Iron

View all →

This 410 Revolver Shotgun Is The BEST of 2023

This review highlights several versatile firearms capable of firing both .410 shells and other handgun calibers. The Taurus Judge Public Defender and Smith & Wesson Governor offer .45 Colt compatibility, while the Raging Judge adds .454 Casull. For a unique shotgun experience, the DP-12 provides a double-barrel, bullpup design. The BFR and Bond Arms Derringer are also noted for their robust build and caliber versatility.

410 Revolver Shotgun

Shotgun

Channel:Best Iron

Category:Reviews

Date: Jun 23, 2023

Duration: 25:08

TOP 10 Best Handguns Under $300 BUILD For 2024! Review

This video provides an expert review of the top 10 best handguns available for under $300 in 2024. The instructor highlights budget-friendly options that do not compromise on reliability, covering models from Taurus, Ruger, Smith & Wesson, Canik, and more. Specific details on capacity, caliber, and performance in endurance tests are discussed, offering valuable insights for budget-conscious firearm owners.

Taurus G2C

Ruger Security-9

Channel:Best Iron

Category:Reviews

Date: May 16, 2022

Duration: 8:19

TOP 5 Best 9mm Carbines Under $400 BUILD In 2024 REVIEW

This video reviews the top 5 best 9mm carbines under $400, highlighting their features, price points, and value. The expert instructor emphasizes affordability and functionality for home defense and range use. Key models discussed include the Kel-Tec Sub 2000, Hi-Point 995TS, Chiappa M1-9, Ruger PC Carbine, and PSA Gen4 AR-9, with a focus on magazine compatibility and portability.

9mm Carbine

Kel-Tec Sub 2000

Channel:Best Iron

Category:Reviews

Date: May 19, 2022

Duration: 8:07

Keanu Reeves Shows His TOP 8 Private Gun Collection

This entry details the firearms and training methodologies showcased in the context of the John Wick film series, highlighting Keanu Reeves' dedication and the specific firearms used. It draws upon the expertise of instructors like Taran Butler, emphasizing realistic gun handling and cinematic techniques. The content covers specific models from Heckler & Koch, Benelli, Taran Tactical Innovations, STI, SIG Sauer, Kel-Tec, and Desert Tactical Arms, offering insights into their tactical relevance and movie portrayal.

John Wick

Keanu Reeves

Channel:Best Iron

Category:Tactical & Gear

Date: Apr 19, 2023

Duration: 12:18

Find an FFL

Licensed dealers in your area

Supreme Court UNANIMOUS Decision To REMOVE 2A

Tags

Quick Summary

Chapters

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Supreme Court's decision in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruen?

How did the Bruen decision change the legal standard for gun control laws?

What are the implications of the Bruen decision for other states?

Who wrote the majority opinion in the Bruen case, and what was the vote count?

Related Articles

Sig Sauer P365: Complete Guide

Springfield Hellcat Pro: Complete Guide

Canik MC9 Prime: Complete Guide

Common Use: The Math, the Law, and the 24 Million AR-15s in American Hands

Related News

US Supreme Court won’t hear challenge to Chicago lawsuit against gun shop - FOX 32 Chicago

Supreme Court Lets Chicago Suit Against Indiana Dealer Proceed - Hoodline

Minnesota Senate approves gun control package, but it’s unlikely to pass House - Minnesota Reformer

Op-Ed on Minnesota Gun Control Offers Myopic View of Issue

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Best Iron