Terrible New 9th Circuit Decision Destroys Carry In California May v. Bonta

Published on January 16, 2025
Duration: 9:50

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has denied an en banc rehearing for the May v. Bonta case, upholding a previous three-judge panel's decision that partially restricts firearm carry in California under SB2. While some locations like hospitals and churches were restored for carry, many others including parks, playgrounds, and stadiums remain off-limits. This decision means the current sensitive location restrictions in California will stand unless further appealed to the Supreme Court or a final judgment is reached at the district court level.

Quick Summary

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has denied an en banc rehearing for the May v. Bonta case, upholding restrictions on firearm carry in California under SB2. Sensitive locations like parks, stadiums, and libraries remain off-limits, though carry is now permitted in private businesses without a specific sign.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Bad News for California Carry
  2. 00:40Sponsor: Attorneys on Retainer
  3. 01:23May v. Bonta and SB2 Sensitive Locations Explained
  4. 03:36Ninth Circuit Three-Judge Panel Decision Breakdown
  5. 04:44Ninth Circuit's Flawed Reasoning and Bruen Conflict
  6. 05:16Denial of En Banc Rehearing: What It Means
  7. 06:35Disappointment and Next Steps for the Case
  8. 07:01Potential Future Legal Avenues: District Court or Supreme Court
  9. 08:07Current State of Sensitive Locations in California
  10. 08:22Impact on National Reciprocity
  11. 09:08Conclusion: A Setback for Firearm Rights

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the latest ruling on California's SB2 gun law from the Ninth Circuit?

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals denied an en banc rehearing for the May v. Bonta case. This means the previous ruling allowing certain firearm carry restrictions under SB2 to stand remains in effect, impacting sensitive locations across California.

Which locations are still considered sensitive under California's SB2 law after the Ninth Circuit's decision?

Following the Ninth Circuit's denial, sensitive locations in California where firearm carry is prohibited include playgrounds, parks, state parks, casinos, stadiums, arenas, libraries, zoos, museums, and their associated parking areas.

Did the Ninth Circuit restore any carry rights previously restricted by SB2?

Yes, the Ninth Circuit's earlier three-judge panel decision did allow carry in some locations like hospitals, churches, and medical facilities. The 'vampire rule' for private businesses was also enjoined, permitting carry without a specific sign.

What are the next potential legal steps for the May v. Bonta case after the Ninth Circuit's denial?

The case could be sent back to the district court for a final judgment, or the plaintiffs could appeal the injunction and the Ninth Circuit's decision directly to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Copper Jacket TV

View all →