This Week in Guns 11/16/23 - Several Case Updates, New York & Other States Wilding, + Why We're Mad

This CRPA TV episode, featuring Chuck Michel, discusses the significant legal developments in the Duncan v. Bonta case concerning California's magazine capacity ban. A recent DC court ruling has created a circuit split, potentially increasing the Supreme Court's likelihood of hearing the Duncan case. The discussion highlights the legal reasoning behind the DC ruling, emphasizing that standard-capacity magazines are considered 'arms' for lawful use.

William Kirk of Washington Gun Law critically analyzes the Department of Justice's (DOJ) legal arguments against Second Amendment principles concerning the National Firearms Act (NFA). The DOJ's stance, as presented in the *Silencer Shop Foundation, et. al v. ATF* case, challenges congressional intent for $0 taxation on NFA items to mean no registration. Kirk highlights the DOJ's reliance on the Commerce Clause and historical legal precedents like *Miller* and *Heller* to defend NFA regulations, arguing these items are 'quintessentially economic' and 'particularly susceptible to criminal misuse'. This interpretation is seen as a significant setback for gun rights advocates.

This video discusses the legal challenge to California's ban on firearm magazines holding more than ten rounds in the landmark Duncan v. Bonta case. CRPA President Chuck Michel and Kevin Small break down California's opposition brief, exploring arguments related to the 'takings clause,' the definition of 'arms' under the Second Amendment, and historical parallels. The discussion highlights how this case could be the most significant Second Amendment legal battle since the Bruen decision and anticipates its potential path to the U.S. Supreme Court, with implications for gun owners nationwide. It also touches on the influence of gun control advocacy groups and recent DOJ reversals.

This video discusses a significant legal ruling in Florida that has struck down the state's open carry ban as unconstitutional. The decision, influenced by Supreme Court precedents, asserts that the Second Amendment right to bear arms includes the right to carry openly. The ban, previously enforced under Statute 790.053, meant citizens had to conceal firearms or face arrest. The ruling, stemming from an incident on July 4th, 2022, has immediate implications for law enforcement and citizens across Florida, potentially setting a precedent for other states.

This video provides an expert-level analysis of a significant legal challenge to the National Firearms Act (NFA) and its restrictions on Short Barreled Rifles (SBRs), currently before the Supreme Court. The case, USA v. Rush, argues that NFA regulations on SBRs infringe upon Second Amendment rights, citing recent Supreme Court decisions like Bruen and Rahimi. The discussion highlights lower court confusion regarding protected arms and the potential implications for various firearm restrictions.

This video from Four Boxes Diner, hosted by constitutional attorney Mark W. Smith, discusses a significant Second Amendment victory in the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit concerning young Americans' rights. The analysis touches on historical methodology in Second Amendment cases, common arguments made by anti-gun judges, and specifically addresses arguments against gun ownership for individuals aged 18-20. The host also references his legal scholarship and a previous court case where his work was cited.

This video showcases the B&T BWC-9, a unique briefcase-style firearm, demonstrating its rapid deployment and compact form factor. It highlights the weapon's compatibility with Glock slides and barrels, its folding mechanism, and its potential for home defense or specialized carry. The content emphasizes the satirical and expert nature of the presentation by firearms attorney Matt Larosiere.

Othais, host of C&Rsenal and a recognized firearm expert, conducted an open carry experiment with a 1911 pistol in Condition 1 ('cocked and locked'). He observed that many 'Fudds' (older firearm enthusiasts) expressed concern about the hammer being back, indicating a lack of awareness regarding this common and safe carry method for 1911-style pistols. This experiment highlights a generational gap in firearm knowledge and public perception.

This short showcases a critical mechanical failure of the brand-new Daniel Defense H9 pistol at SHOT Show 2024, where the magazine base plate detached unexpectedly. The video highlights the immediate consequence of this failure, with the magazine spring and follower falling out. Despite the product issue, the video uses humor to comment on the situation.

Bill Wilson of Wilson Combat humorously warns against dropping the slide on an empty magazine, stating it's bad practice and jokingly equates it to a kitten's demise. The video showcases various 1911 models at the Wilson Combat booth during Shot Show 2024, highlighting proper firearm handling and etiquette.