WOW! New York To Ban 2nd Amendment On State/County/City Property?!

Published on February 21, 2023
Duration: 7:31

This video provides an expert analysis of New York's proposed Bill S. 4911, which seeks to ban firearm and ammunition sales on state, county, and municipal properties. The speaker, citing legal precedent like the *NY State Rifle & Pistol Assoc. Inc. v. Bruen* Supreme Court case and referencing conversations with legal experts, argues the bill is an unconstitutional infringement on Second Amendment rights, particularly on taxpayer-funded properties. The analysis highlights the bill's definitions, penalties, and its broader implications for gun ownership and sales in New York.

Quick Summary

New York Bill S. 4911 proposes banning firearm and ammunition sales on state, county, city, municipal, and fairground properties, classifying violations as Class A misdemeanors. The bill's justification references the *NY State Rifle & Pistol Assoc. Inc. v. Bruen* Supreme Court decision. Critics argue this ban infringes on Second Amendment rights on taxpayer-funded property, and New York has faced legal procedural issues, such as missing a filing deadline in the Vanderstock case.

Chapters

  1. 00:00New York Gun Sales Ban Proposal
  2. 00:20Blackout Coffee Investment/Sale
  3. 01:11NY Gun Law Restrictiveness
  4. 01:47Analysis of NY Bill S. 4911
  5. 03:07Taxpayer Property & 2nd Amendment
  6. 04:24Bill's Justification & Supreme Court
  7. 05:36NY Legal Challenges & Deadlines
  8. 06:49Future of 2nd Amendment in NY

Frequently Asked Questions

What is New York Bill S. 4911 proposing?

New York Bill S. 4911 aims to ban the sale of firearms, rifles, shotguns, and ammunition on all state, county, city, municipal, and fairground properties. Violations are classified as Class A misdemeanors.

How does the *Bruen* decision relate to New York's proposed gun laws?

The justification for New York Bill S. 4911 explicitly references the US Supreme Court's decision in *New York State Rifle and Pistol Assoc. Inc. v. Bruen*. The bill seeks to implement measures related to licensing, sensitive locations, and safe storage, potentially in response to or in an attempt to navigate the *Bruen* ruling.

What legal issues has New York faced regarding gun laws?

New York has faced legal challenges concerning its gun laws. Notably, the state reportedly missed a filing deadline in the Vanderstock case, an oversight that could prompt further intervention from the Supreme Court and potentially impact future gun control legislation.

Why is banning gun sales on taxpayer-funded property considered controversial?

The argument presented is that banning firearm sales on public property, which is funded by taxpayers, infringes upon citizens' Second Amendment rights. This perspective holds that taxpayers collectively own these properties, and restrictions on sales there are seen as unconstitutional.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Guns & Gadgets 2nd Amendment News

View all →