EDC Pistols | Iron Sights vs Red Dot (Which Should You Carry?)

Published on October 4, 2025
Duration: 13:29

This discussion from Classic Firearms explores the debate between carrying a concealed pistol with traditional iron sights versus a modern red dot optic. Firearms instructors Eliza Madam Thornberry and Jason highlight the pros and cons of each system, emphasizing factors like ease of use, target acquisition, low-light performance, and dependability. The consensus leans towards red dots as a 'force multiplier' for their target-focused aiming, though iron sights remain a reliable option.

Quick Summary

Red dot sights are increasingly favored for concealed carry due to their target-focused aiming, which simplifies sight alignment and can speed up target acquisition. While iron sights are dependable, red dots offer advantages in low-light conditions and can be easier for new shooters to learn with.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Iron Sights vs. Red Dot Dilemma
  2. 00:46Welcome & Guest Introduction: Eliza Madam Thornberry
  3. 01:12Concealed Carry Topic: Irons vs. Red Dots
  4. 01:46Starting with Iron Sights: Glock & Sig Sauer
  5. 02:01Critique of Stock Glock Sights
  6. 03:01Importance of Low Light Sights
  7. 03:41Sig Sauer P365 XL & X-Ray Sights
  8. 04:17Upgrading Iron Sights: AmeriGlo
  9. 04:53Sight Height & Snagging Concerns
  10. 05:14Hybrid Red Dot & Iron Sight Setups
  11. 05:41The Red Dot Revolution
  12. 06:00Red Dot Advantages: Simplicity & Target Focus
  13. 06:17Trijicon RMR: The Gold Standard
  14. 06:51Co-witnessing Through Red Dots
  15. 07:33Red Dots on Smaller Concealed Carry Pistols
  16. 08:22Full-Size Carry with Red Dot: Glock 17 & Acro
  17. 08:35Occluded Eye Training & Dry Fire
  18. 09:05Single Plane Aiming vs. Two-Plane Alignment
  19. 09:16Probability of First Hit with Red Dots
  20. 09:52Duty vs. Concealed Carry Optics
  21. 10:00Trijicon SRO: Competition Optic
  22. 10:40Red Dot Reliability & Failure Points
  23. 10:49Open vs. Closed Emitter Red Dots
  24. 11:09Conclusion: Irons vs. Red Dots
  25. 11:16Guest's Decision: Moving to Team Red Dot
  26. 11:21Target Focus vs. Sight Focus
  27. 11:52Red Dots as Force Multipliers
  28. 12:02Final Thoughts on Starting with Red Dots
  29. 12:10Recommendation: Start with a Red Dot
  30. 12:23Simplifying Firearm Manipulation
  31. 13:07Viewer Engagement: Your Preference?
  32. 13:24Thank You & Farewell

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main advantages of iron sights for concealed carry?

Iron sights are highly dependable, require no batteries, and have a proven track record for accuracy. They are a robust and simple aiming system that works in all conditions without electronic failure points.

Why are red dot sights becoming popular for concealed carry?

Red dot sights offer a significant advantage in target acquisition by allowing the shooter to focus on the target and place the dot on it, rather than aligning multiple sight elements. This can lead to faster and more intuitive aiming, especially under stress.

How do iron sights and red dots perform in low-light conditions?

While stock iron sights on some firearms (like Glocks) are poor in low light, upgraded sights with tritium or photoluminescent elements offer visibility. Red dot sights inherently provide a visible aiming point (the illuminated dot) in low light, making them advantageous.

Should beginners start with iron sights or red dot sights?

The consensus from instructors in the video suggests starting with a red dot sight. They argue it removes guesswork, simplifies aiming, and allows new shooters to focus on fundamental shooting mechanics more effectively.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from ClassicFirearms

View all →