pocket auto vs pocket revolver

Published on November 26, 2014
Duration: 13:53

John Hickok, an experienced firearms instructor, provides an expert comparison between pocket semi-automatic pistols and revolvers for concealed carry. He highlights key differences in size, capacity, reloading, and shooter familiarity, offering practical insights gained from extensive personal carry experience and range testing. Hickok's assessment emphasizes the advantages of thinness and higher capacity in semi-autos for pocket carry while acknowledging the continued relevance of quality revolvers for those who prefer them.

Quick Summary

John Hickok compares pocket semi-automatic pistols and revolvers, highlighting that semi-autos are thinner, easier to conceal, and offer higher capacity, while revolvers can be thicker but may fire a more powerful round. He stresses the importance of testing pocket guns for lint-related reliability and notes that semi-autos are generally easier for most shooters to operate and reload under stress.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Pocket Lint
  2. 01:30Size & Thickness Comparison
  3. 02:30Length & Ergonomics
  4. 04:10Capacity & Caliber Trade-offs
  5. 05:30Reloading Speed
  6. 07:10Shooter Familiarity
  7. 09:35Range Performance
  8. 11:30Final Thoughts

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between pocket semi-automatic pistols and pocket revolvers for concealed carry?

Pocket semi-automatics are typically thinner, offering better concealability and less printing, while revolvers are thicker due to their cylinders. Semi-autos also generally boast higher ammunition capacity and easier magazine reloads under stress compared to revolver speed loaders.

How does pocket lint affect the reliability of concealed carry firearms?

Pocket lint and debris can accumulate in the action or cylinder of firearms carried in pockets, potentially causing malfunctions. Regular cleaning and testing in a 'carried' state are crucial for ensuring reliability, especially for pocket guns.

Which type of pocket pistol is easier for a beginner to shoot effectively?

Modern striker-fired semi-automatic pistols are often easier for beginners to master due to simpler manual of arms and trigger pulls compared to the double-action triggers and specific techniques required for revolvers.

What are the trade-offs between .380 ACP in a semi-auto and .38 Special in a revolver for self-defense?

While .38 Special is generally considered more powerful than .380 ACP, semi-automatic pistols often carry more rounds (e.g., 6+1 vs. 5), providing more opportunities to stop a threat. The choice depends on balancing caliber power with capacity and shooter proficiency.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from John Hickok

View all →