Why I Wouldn’t Carry A 1911

Published on May 10, 2025
Duration: 0:58

This guide, informed by an experienced practitioner, details why a full-sized 1911 might not be ideal for everyday concealed carry (EDC). It covers assessing the firearm's physical footprint, comparing it to subcompacts, evaluating concealability issues like 'printing,' and considering the practical implications of .45 ACP recoil versus 9mm. The speaker suggests that while not optimal for EDC, the 1911 can still be a viable option for open carry during training or outdoor activities.

Quick Summary

A full-sized 1911 is often not ideal for everyday concealed carry (EDC) due to its physical footprint, weight, and tendency to 'print' through clothing. While its 7+1 capacity in .45 ACP is a consideration, comfort and concealability issues are more significant. Modern subcompacts generally offer better ergonomics for daily carry, though a 1911 can be suitable for open carry scenarios.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Capacity vs. Practicality
  2. 00:14Size, Weight, and Comfort
  3. 00:31Concealability and Printing
  4. 00:36Recoil and Training
  5. 00:48Conclusion and Open Carry

Frequently Asked Questions

Why might a 1911 not be suitable for everyday concealed carry (EDC)?

A full-sized 1911's physical footprint, including its weight and dimensions, can make it uncomfortable for long-term daily concealed carry. Issues like 'printing' (the gun's outline showing through clothing) are also significant concerns, often making modern subcompacts a more practical choice for EDC.

What are the main drawbacks of carrying a 1911 for self-defense?

The primary drawbacks are its larger size and heavier weight, which impact comfort and concealability for daily carry. While capacity is often debated, the physical dimensions and potential for 'printing' are more critical factors for EDC than the 7+1 round count of .45 ACP.

How does the recoil of a .45 ACP 1911 compare to a 9mm, and why is it important for carry?

.45 ACP generally has more felt recoil than 9mm. For concealed carry, this increased 'kick' can lead to poorer shot placement or slower follow-up shots if the carrier lacks consistent training to manage it effectively. Consistent practice is key for both calibers.

Is a 1911 ever a good choice for carry?

While not ideal for everyday concealed carry due to size and weight, a 1911 can be suitable for open carry during training, range activities, or outdoor pursuits where concealment is not a primary concern. Its classic design and handling characteristics remain appealing for these scenarios.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from Shatterthewicked

View all →