Q&A 29: Galilean Sights and American AKs

Published on May 23, 2019
Duration: 61:26

This Q&A session covers a wide range of firearms topics, from recommendations for a first C&R purchase (Polish P83, Radom VIS 35, Mauser 98) to historical firearms like the Hotchkiss revolving cannon and Galilean sights. Ian McCallum discusses the nuances of black powder cartridges, the advantages of repeating rifles like the Kropatschek, and the historical context of Luger production. He also touches on modern firearm design, the challenges of American-made AKs, and the effectiveness of various submachine guns. The discussion extends to book publishing, the impact of media on the gun world, and personal perspectives on expertise and collecting.

Quick Summary

For a first C&R purchase focusing on Polish firearms, consider the P83 pistol, often available for $100-$230, offering historical interest from the Cold War. If budget allows, the Radom VIS 35, a Polish take on the 1911, is another excellent option. Polish Mauser 98 rifles are also viable choices.

Chapters

  1. 00:02:00First C&R Purchase Recommendations (Polish Guns)
  2. 00:04:01Hotchkiss Revolving Cannon Black Powder Use
  3. 00:05:34Finding Primary Sources for Research
  4. 00:07:51Media's Impact on the Gun World
  5. 00:09:14Forgotten Weapons Amazon Prime Content
  6. 00:10:21Future Books from Headstamp Publishing
  7. 00:12:21Historical Pistol-to-Carbine Conversion Kits
  8. 00:16:13WWI Trench Loadout: MP 18 vs. RSC 1917
  9. 00:17:37Black Powder Cartridge Similarities to Modern Ones
  10. 00:19:17Kropatschek Rifle vs. Gras Rifle Advantage
  11. 00:22:59Interarms Imported Luger & Swiss Tooling
  12. 00:25:54Update on 'Shot Spotter' Book & Future Projects
  13. 00:31:36Top 3 Open-Bolt SMGs (Owen, Beretta 38A, ZK 383)
  14. 00:33:41Defining Expertise & Imposter Syndrome
  15. 00:36:01Favorite Learnings from 'Shot Spotter' Book
  16. 00:38:14AK Gas Piston & DI System Modifications
  17. 00:39:04Gewehr 98: 7x57mm vs. 8x57mm Cartridge
  18. 00:40:25Firearm Design Inspiration & Standardization
  19. 00:41:29Downsides of MAC M11 Machine Gun Ownership
  20. 00:43:33Machine Gun Ownership: Recreational vs. Practical
  21. 00:44:33Galilean Sights on WWI Rifles
  22. 00:47:10'Property of US Government' Markings & Resale Value
  23. 00:48:55Pre-NFA Suppressor Ownership & Rarity
  24. 00:51:30WWI Night Sights on Rifles & Machine Guns
  25. 00:53:01American-Made AKs vs. Surplus Parts Kits
  26. 00:56:25Desert Brutality Match Loadout Ideas
  27. 00:59:43Current Firearms 'Chased' for Review/Ownership (Cal Toph Repeater)

Frequently Asked Questions

What are good C&R firearm recommendations for a first-time collector interested in Polish guns?

For a first C&R purchase focusing on Polish firearms, consider the P83 pistol, often available for $100-$230, offering historical interest from the Cold War. If budget allows, the Radom VIS 35, a Polish take on the 1911, is another excellent option. Polish Mauser 98 rifles are also viable choices.

Why were some Hotchkiss revolving cannons specified for black powder only?

The specification for black powder only on certain Hotchkiss revolving cannon reproductions is primarily a liability measure. It's impossible to over-pressurize the action with black powder, unlike smokeless .50 BMG, thus preventing potentially destructive failures and protecting the manufacturer from liability.

What is the historical significance of the Interarms imported Luger?

Interarms imported Lugers manufactured by Mauser post-WWII used tooling acquired from the Swiss. This tooling resulted in the characteristic straight front grip strap, distinct from standard German Lugers. The process involved significant challenges due to worn tooling and differing manufacturing philosophies.

Are Galilean sights still relevant for modern firearms?

Galilean sights, used on WWI rifles, are simple tubeless telescopes offering minimal magnification (around 2x) and a small field of view. They are generally considered a poor alternative to modern optics or even iron sights and are not relevant for contemporary firearms.

Why are American-made AKs often seen as inferior to surplus parts kits?

American-made AKs are often built on a budget to compete with inexpensive surplus kits. Original Soviet bloc AKs were manufactured without budget constraints, resulting in higher quality. American manufacturers must cut costs, leading to perceived inferiority, not a lack of capability to produce good AKs.

More General Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →