Q&A 34: Brought to you by Scotch

Published on October 24, 2019
Duration: 84:51

This Q&A session from Forgotten Weapons covers a wide range of firearms topics, including the rationale behind publishing video formats, the history and design of various firearms like the Webley Fosbury and M1 Garand, discussions on magazine safeties, and the viability of certain firearm designs. Ian McCollum, drawing on his extensive knowledge, addresses questions about historical firearms, modern design considerations, and collecting advice.

Quick Summary

Publishing too many videos on a single topic consecutively can lead to audience boredom and decreased engagement. This was observed in the 'infamous Bergman series,' where a high volume of related content resulted in declining views and viewer interest over time.

Chapters

  1. 00:00:00Introduction & Sponsorship
  2. 00:00:49Video Publishing Strategy
  3. 00:02:58Filming Volume & Stamina
  4. 00:05:22Self-Cocking Revolvers
  5. 00:06:34Surplus Rifle Budgeting
  6. 00:07:00Magazine Safeties Explained
  7. 00:09:26Right Gun, Right Time: WWII Examples
  8. 00:12:13Cylinder Gap & Revolver Carbines
  9. 00:14:33Missed Filming Opportunities
  10. 00:15:42Tilting Bolt Battle Rifles
  11. 00:17:35Favorite Lee-Enfield Variant
  12. 00:18:38SVT-40 Impact on WWII
  13. 00:20:02Modern Pistol Preferences
  14. 00:20:35VZ 58 Magazine Viability
  15. 00:23:07Germany & Smokeless Powder
  16. 00:25:15Japanese Rifle Book Plans
  17. 00:26:28Gewehr 41M Charging Handle System
  18. 00:28:48Britain's Webley Revolver Reliance
  19. 00:31:10M1 Garand Folding Stock Trials
  20. 00:33:44British Top Brake Revolver Books
  21. 00:35:30Gewehr 1888 Thoughts
  22. 00:37:37Machine Gun Registry Future
  23. 00:39:02Straight Pull vs. Turn Bolt Actions
  24. 00:40:26Hearing Protection Choices
  25. 00:42:01Best Book for Japanese Rifles
  26. 00:43:09Red Dot Sights on WWII Rifles
  27. 00:44:27NFA Registry Access
  28. 00:44:4845 Degree Downward Ejection
  29. 00:45:31Type 99 Arisaka AA Sights
  30. 00:46:439mm Luger Dominance
  31. 00:47:28PDW Choice: VP70 vs. M712
  32. 00:48:43Modern Toggle-Lock Pistols
  33. 00:49:09Favorite .22 Caliber Plinkers
  34. 00:49:47Western Military Arms Production
  35. 00:52:27WWII Firearms Books
  36. 00:54:30Great Guns That Failed Commercially
  37. 00:57:26Franklin Armory Reformation & Straight Rifling
  38. 00:58:41WWII Extended & G30 Platform
  39. 00:59:54Reduced Load 7.62x51mm Cartridge
  40. 01:02:02Ultimate German Sniper Rifle?
  41. 01:02:38Left-Handed M1 Garand Reloading
  42. 01:04:25Most Desired Unshootable Firearms
  43. 01:06:11Project Lightning Origins
  44. 01:06:53Visiting Russia
  45. 01:08:41Impact of Audience Support

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is publishing too many videos on one topic a bad idea?

Publishing too many videos on a single topic consecutively can lead to audience boredom and decreased engagement. This was observed in the 'infamous Bergman series,' where a high volume of related content resulted in declining views and viewer interest over time.

What are some notable self-cocking revolvers?

Besides the Webley Fosbury, other self-cocking revolvers include the Union Automatic Revolver from the US and the Italian Mattia Bob. However, these are generally not considered practical for modern use and are primarily of historical or collector interest.

What is the purpose of a magazine safety?

Magazine safeties are primarily designed for large-scale firearm issuance to personnel with limited training. They prevent accidental discharge if the magazine is removed but the chamber is not checked, adding a layer of safety in high-volume scenarios.

What were the best guns of WWII, considering the right gun at the right time?

Two prime examples are the British Sten gun, developed rapidly and produced in vast numbers to meet wartime needs, and the US M1 Garand, which provided a significant semi-automatic advantage over bolt-action rifles used by adversaries.

Why did Britain stick with the Webley revolver for so long?

Britain continued with Webley revolvers due to their simplicity, reliability, and ease of training for non-frontline personnel like pilots and vehicle crews. While less effective than modern automatics, they offered a reliable baseline for a wide range of users.

More General Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →