Why Drum Magazines are a Bad Idea

Published on January 9, 2020
Duration: 8:48

Ian McCollum, a recognized expert in historical firearms, explains why drum magazines are less common than box magazines. He details their mechanical complexity, reliability issues due to multi-axis feeding, and logistical disadvantages in portability and carrying spares. Historical examples like the Thompson, Suomi, PPSH-41, and RPK are used to illustrate the military's consistent shift towards more reliable and logistically sound box magazines.

Quick Summary

Drum magazines are less common than box magazines due to their mechanical complexity, making them harder to manufacture reliably. They also present logistical challenges, as they are bulky and inefficient for carrying spares compared to multiple box magazines.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & The BAR Question
  2. 00:53Mechanical Complexity and Reliability
  3. 01:21Portability and Logistics
  4. 03:05Historical Case Study: The Thompson
  5. 04:38Evolution of Soviet and Finnish SMGs
  6. 06:34The RPK and Modern Light Support Weapons
  7. 07:55The German MP40/1 Solution

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are drum magazines less common than box magazines in firearms?

Drum magazines are less common due to their inherent mechanical complexity, which makes them harder to manufacture reliably. The circular feeding path requires more intricate mechanisms prone to failure compared to the simpler straight-line feed of box magazines.

What are the logistical disadvantages of drum magazines?

Drum magazines are bulky and awkward to carry, especially when transporting spares. Soldiers can carry significantly more total ammunition using multiple, lighter box magazines on their gear, making box magazines more logistically efficient.

Can you provide historical examples of military preference for box magazines over drums?

Yes, the US military shifted from drum to box magazines for the Thompson SMG. Similarly, the Soviet PPSH-41 and Finnish Suomi, initially using drums, later favored box magazines for reliability and cost-effectiveness.

Are drum magazines inherently unreliable?

Drum magazines are not inherently unreliable, but their complex mechanical design, involving feeding cartridges along two axes, makes them more susceptible to malfunctions than simpler box magazines, especially in harsh field conditions.

Related News

All News →

More General Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →