1851 Navy Revolver: Deluxe Engraved .44

Published on January 2, 2024
Duration: 11:04

This review covers the Pieta 1851 Navy Deluxe Engraved Edition in .44 caliber. The presenter highlights its 'fantasy gun' aspects, including plastic grips that don't fit well, a brass frame (historically steel), and the .44 caliber (historically .36). Despite these deviations, the engraving, particularly on the cylinder depicting the Battle of Campeche, is praised. The review includes a demonstration of loading with paper cartridges and light powder loads (20.5 grains) to preserve the brass frame, along with chronograph data for these light loads.

Quick Summary

The Pieta 1851 Navy Deluxe Engraved Edition is termed a 'fantasy gun' due to its brass frame and .44 caliber, deviating from the historical steel-framed .36 caliber 1851 Navy. While the plastic grips are a noted flaw, the detailed cylinder engraving is a highlight. For brass frames, lighter loads (around 20.5 grains) and round balls are recommended to minimize stress.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: 1851 Navy Deluxe Engraved Edition
  2. 00:30Why it's a 'Fantasy Gun'
  3. 00:45Grip Complaint: Plastic and Poor Fit
  4. 01:21Brass Frame vs. Steel Frame History
  5. 02:21Caliber Deviation: .44 vs. .36
  6. 03:10Rammer Issue in .44 Conversion
  7. 03:20Engraving Details: Cylinder Battle of Campeche
  8. 04:31Loading and Firing Demonstration
  9. 04:55Paper Cartridge Preparation
  10. 05:05Brass Frame Longevity and Light Loads
  11. 05:48Shooting Impression and Group Analysis
  12. 09:39Chronograph Test: 44 Light Paper Cartridges
  13. 10:25Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes the Pieta 1851 Navy Deluxe Engraved Edition a 'fantasy gun'?

It's considered a 'fantasy gun' due to deviations from historical accuracy. Key differences include a brass frame instead of the original steel, and it's chambered in .44 caliber, whereas the historical 1851 Navy was .36 caliber. The plastic grips also contribute to this designation due to their poor fit and discomfort.

What are the main complaints about the Pieta 1851 Navy Deluxe Engraved Edition?

The primary complaints are the ill-fitting, uncomfortable plastic grips and the use of a brass frame, which is less historically accurate and potentially less durable than steel. The .44 caliber conversion also presents a minor issue with the rammer assembly not being fully optimized.

How does the engraving on this Pieta revolver compare to others?

The engraving, particularly on the cylinder depicting the Battle of Campeche, is highly praised for its clarity and detail, even though it's laser-engraved. It's considered some of the best engraving the presenter has seen on purchased revolvers.

What are the recommended loads for a brass-framed 1851 Navy replica?

For brass-framed revolvers like this Pieta 1851 Navy, it's recommended to use lighter powder loads to preserve the frame's integrity over time. The presenter uses 20.5 grains of powder and round balls, which reduces pressure and bearing surface in the bore compared to heavier loads and conical bullets.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Guns of the West

View all →