ATA Arms SP vs Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon 1

Published on May 2, 2018
Duration: 35:15

This expert review by Johnny from TGS Outdoors provides a detailed technical comparison between the ATA Arms SP Sporting and the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon 1. The analysis highlights significant differences in stock design, internal action mechanics, barrel specifications, and overall balance, concluding that while the ATA offers value, the Beretta excels in refinement and proven design.

Quick Summary

Expert analysis reveals the ATA Arms SP Sporting (£600) and Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon 1 (£1650 new) differ significantly. The Beretta boasts a superior trigger plate action, better stock ergonomics, and neutral balance, while the ATA has a top-loaded sear, wider grip, and is front-heavy. The Beretta is considered more refined, though the ATA offers good value.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Comparison Premise
  2. 01:29Stock and Grip Analysis
  3. 10:11Fore-end Design and Weight
  4. 13:46Barrel Specifications and Ejectors
  5. 19:29Internal Action Mechanics
  6. 26:43Handling and Balance
  7. 31:19Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the ATA Arms SP Sporting and the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon 1?

The Beretta 686 features a superior trigger plate action, better stock ergonomics, and a single-piece fore-end iron, while the ATA SP has a top-loaded sear, a wider grip, and a two-piece fore-end. The Beretta also offers adjustable LOP, unlike the ATA's fixed length.

Is the ATA Arms SP Sporting a direct copy of the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon 1?

No, despite rumors, the ATA Arms SP Sporting is not a direct copy. While both are 12 Gauge sporting shotguns, they have distinct internal mechanics, action widths, barrel specifications, and balance characteristics, indicating significant design differences.

Which shotgun offers better value for money, the ATA SP or the Beretta 686?

The ATA Arms SP Sporting offers impressive functionality for its £600 price point, making it a good value. However, the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon 1, despite its higher cost, is considered superior in overall refinement, build quality, and proven design, justifying its premium.

How do the barrels and actions differ between the ATA SP and Beretta 686?

The ATA SP barrels are heavier (1490g) with a 18.4mm bore, while the Beretta 686 barrels are lighter (1390g) with an 18.6mm bore. Internally, the Beretta uses a highly regarded trigger plate action, whereas the ATA employs a top-loaded sear, resulting in a different trigger feel.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from TGS Outdoors

View all →