Budget AR-9 PCC vs Ruger PC Carbine 19122 Review

Published on April 27, 2020
Duration: 10:14

This review provides an expert comparison of the Ruger PC Carbine 19122 and a budget Foxtrot Mike AR-9 build, both chambered in 9mm Luger. The analysis, presented with an analytical and objective tone, highlights differences in ergonomics, reliability with various magazines, balance, and recoil impulse. The Ruger is noted for its factory-ready performance and effective recoil mitigation, while the AR-9 offers familiar AR-15 controls and modularity but presents potential feeding issues and a harsher recoil.

Quick Summary

The Ruger PC Carbine 19122 ($650, 7.3 lbs, 16.12" barrel) offers effective recoil management with its dead blow system and reliable performance with OEM Glock mags. A budget Foxtrot Mike AR-9 ($600 est., 6.2 lbs, 16" barrel) provides AR-15 ergonomics but can have feeding issues due to its feed cone and a harsher recoil impulse.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Budget 9mm PCCs
  2. 00:31Ruger PC Carbine 19122 Overview
  3. 01:14Ruger Ergonomics and Handling
  4. 02:33Ruger Reliability and Performance
  5. 03:59Foxtrot Mike AR-9 Overview
  6. 04:49AR-9 Ergonomics and Balance
  7. 06:07AR-9 Reliability Issues
  8. 07:18AR-9 Shooting Performance
  9. 08:50Final Summary

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences in ergonomics between the Ruger PC Carbine and a budget AR-9 build?

The Ruger PC Carbine is noted for being front-heavy and has a safety selector that requires moving the hand off the fire control group, along with a forward magazine release. The AR-9 offers more familiar AR-15 ergonomics and better balance due to its weight distribution behind the grip.

How does the reliability of the Ruger PC Carbine compare with different magazines?

During testing, the Ruger PC Carbine experienced stovepipe malfunctions with ETS 40-round magazines. However, it demonstrated 100% reliability when using OEM Glock magazines, highlighting the importance of magazine compatibility.

What are the potential feeding issues with a budget AR-9 build?

A common issue with budget AR-9 builds can be a small feed cone on the barrel, which may lead to feeding hang-ups and bullet denting. This is particularly noticeable with extended magazines and hollow-point ammunition.

Which 9mm PCC is recommended for recoil management?

The Ruger PC Carbine features a tungsten dead blow system designed to effectively manage recoil, facilitating faster follow-up shots. The AR-9, using a pure blowback action, generally results in a more forceful recoil impulse.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from SuperSetCA

View all →