Did Journalists Lie About This Pistol?

Published on April 23, 2026
Duration: 9:32

This review of the Colt All-American 2000, designed by Reed Knight and Eugene Stoner, challenges historical claims of extreme inaccuracy. While the pistol exhibited reliability issues and a heavy, unusual trigger pull, the reviewer's tests showed significantly better accuracy than reported in early 1990s firearms publications. The reviewer suggests that the pistol's ergonomics, trigger, and potentially manufacturing tolerances contributed to its poor reception, rather than outright fabrication by journalists.

Quick Summary

The Colt All-American 2000, designed by Reed Knight and Eugene Stoner, was reported to be extremely inaccurate, with claims of 25-inch groups at 25 yards. However, independent testing showed groups around 10.5-11.5 inches at the same distance, suggesting historical reports may have been exaggerated or influenced by the pistol's challenging ergonomics and trigger.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Colt All-American 2000
  2. 00:07Designers: Reed Knight & Eugene Stoner
  3. 00:25Commercial Failure & Reception
  4. 00:36Claims of Poor Accuracy
  5. 00:50American Rifleman Claim: 25in Groups
  6. 01:10Fudbusters Loaned Pistols
  7. 01:33Testing the 25in Claim
  8. 01:46Accuracy Results: New Pistol
  9. 02:04Accuracy Results: Worn Pistol
  10. 02:13Unsupported Shooting Method
  11. 02:15Stoppages & Shooting Ability
  12. 02:31Group Size Comparison (Area)
  13. 03:17Expectations vs. Reality
  14. 03:40Accuracy Standard for Modern Pistols
  15. 03:49Glock 17 Comparison Test
  16. 04:04Glock 17 Group Size
  17. 04:08Colt vs. Glock Group Pattern
  18. 04:24Not as Bad as Reported
  19. 04:30Did Journalists Lie?
  20. 04:36Difficulty of Shooting the Pistol
  21. 04:55Overall Impression
  22. 04:58Trigger Pull Weight & Feel
  23. 05:16Ergonomic Design for Small Hands
  24. 05:27Trigger Break & Over-Travel
  25. 05:43Breaking the Shot Without Disturbing Sights
  26. 05:48Shooting Performance Summary
  27. 06:06Comparison to Expert Claims
  28. 06:08Reasons for Perceived Inaccuracy
  29. 06:19Front Sight Play Criticism
  30. 06:25Barrel Bushing Mechanism
  31. 06:29Measuring Bushing Play
  32. 06:37Sight Radius & Impact Shift
  33. 06:49Critique of Bushing Criticism
  34. 06:57Bushing Return to Center
  35. 07:06Normal Operation of Bushing
  36. 07:16Impact of 10k Play
  37. 07:28Emphasis on Loose Bushing
  38. 07:38Likely Causes of Inaccuracy
  39. 07:45Post-Glock Era Design
  40. 07:50Machine Rest Test Suggestion
  41. 07:55Mechanical Accuracy Potential
  42. 07:59Combined Factors for Poor Shooting
  43. 08:14Marksmanship Fundamentals
  44. 08:26Fault of the Gun vs. Shooter
  45. 08:39Overall Negative Impression
  46. 08:43Reliability Issues Recap
  47. 08:46Accuracy & Shootability
  48. 08:52Ergonomic Fit
  49. 08:56Interesting Story & Reception
  50. 09:04FUD Blasters Video Recommendation
  51. 09:08Thanks to Fudbusters
  52. 09:15Review Format Comparison
  53. 09:21Patreon & Channel Support

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the reported accuracy issues with the Colt All-American 2000?

Early 1990s firearms publications claimed extreme inaccuracy for the Colt All-American 2000, with one notable report stating it shot 25-inch groups at 25 yards. This led to its perception as a commercially unsuccessful firearm.

What were the actual accuracy results from testing the Colt All-American 2000?

In testing, the Colt All-American 2000 produced groups of approximately 10.5 inches with a new pistol and 11.5 inches with a worn pistol at 25 yards, shot unsupported. These results are significantly smaller than the widely reported 25-inch groups.

What are the key design features of the Colt All-American 2000?

The Colt All-American 2000 is a rotating barrel, striker-fired, polymer-frame, double-action-only semi-automatic pistol. It was designed by Reed Knight and Eugene Stoner.

What are the main criticisms of the Colt All-American 2000's ergonomics and trigger?

The pistol features a heavy, long, straight-back double-action trigger pull. Its design is intended for smaller hands, but the reviewer found the grip and trigger break point awkward, impacting shooting comfort and control.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from JaredAF

View all →