FN SCAR 16S/17S May you Rest in Peace

Published on November 8, 2025
Duration: 18:43

FN America has discontinued the commercial SCAR 16S and 17S lines in the US. Originally developed for SOCOM to replace the M4A1, the SCAR program faced numerous mechanical issues during trials and early deployment, including parts breakages and feeding problems. While the SCAR 17S saw more adoption, it was known for destroying optics due to recoil and had fragile components. The speaker, Chris Bartocci, highlights that aftermarket parts from companies like Geissele and KDG were often necessary to make the rifle reliable and ergonomic, turning it into a 'boutique' rifle. Owners are advised to stockpile spare parts due to the discontinuation.

Quick Summary

FN America has discontinued the commercial SCAR 16S and 17S models in the US market. Originally developed for SOCOM, the SCAR faced numerous mechanical issues and required extensive aftermarket upgrades for reliability, making it a costly 'boutique' rifle. Owners should stockpile spare parts immediately.

Chapters

  1. 00:00SCAR 16S/17S Discontinuation Announcement
  2. 00:57SCAR Program Origins & SOCOM Needs
  3. 02:13FN vs. Colt Type C Competition
  4. 03:38SCAR Mechanical Failures & Trial Issues
  5. 04:30M4A1 Improvements (SOPMOD Block 1)
  6. 05:58SCAR 17S (Heavy) Specific Problems
  7. 07:30Essential Aftermarket Solutions
  8. 09:14Kinetic Development Group Upgrades
  9. 10:13The SCAR as a 'Boutique' Rifle
  10. 11:28Future of FN Rifles & New Cartridge
  11. 12:51Advice for Current SCAR Owners: Stockpile Parts

Frequently Asked Questions

Why has FN America discontinued the SCAR 16S and 17S in the US?

FN America has officially ceased production of the commercial SCAR 16S and 17S models for the US market. While the exact reasons are not fully detailed, the rifle's history of mechanical issues, high cost, and the availability of more practical alternatives likely contributed to this decision.

What were the main problems with the FN SCAR during its trials and deployment?

The SCAR faced significant issues including parts breakages, trigger module failures, and feeding problems like double and triple feeds. The SCAR 17S model was particularly noted for destroying optics due to recoil harmonics and having fragile components like stock hinges.

Are aftermarket parts necessary for the FN SCAR 16S/17S?

Yes, due to factory flaws, many owners found aftermarket parts essential. Companies like Geissele (triggers), Handl Defense (lowers), and Kinetic Development Group (handguards, stocks) provided crucial upgrades to improve reliability and ergonomics.

What advice is given to current FN SCAR owners?

Owners are strongly advised to immediately stockpile critical spare parts such as bolts, firing pins, and extractors, as these will become scarce. Barrels, already expensive, are also expected to see significant price increases on the secondary market.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from SmallArmsSolutions

View all →