Girsan Match X or MAC9DS Comp?

Published on July 29, 2025
Duration: 2:57

Roger Barrera of QVO Tactical provides a critical comparison of the EAA Girsan Witness 2311 Match X and the MAC9DS Comp, two budget-friendly 2011-style pistols. He highlights the Girsan's smooth action but criticizes its restrictive RMSC optic cut and out-of-spec accessory rail. The MAC9DS Comp is favored for its RMR optic footprint and functional accessory rail. The assessment is based on professional experience with tactical gear and firearms.

Quick Summary

Roger Barrera of QVO Tactical compares the Girsan Witness 2311 Match X and MAC9DS Comp, highlighting the MAC9DS's superior RMR optic cut and in-spec accessory rail over the Girsan's out-of-spec rail and limited RMSC cut.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Comparison Setup
  2. 00:29Girsan Match X Performance and Pricing
  3. 01:11Girsan Match X Drawbacks
  4. 01:41MAC9DS Comp Features
  5. 02:11Trigger Comparison and Final Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Girsan Witness 2311 Match X and the MAC9DS Comp?

The Girsan Match X features a smooth action but has an out-of-spec accessory rail and a restrictive RMSC optic cut. The MAC9DS Comp offers an RMR optic footprint, an in-spec accessory rail, and a metal magwell, making it the preferred choice for accessory compatibility.

Which pistol is better for mounting accessories like lights?

The MAC9DS Comp is better for mounting accessories due to its in-spec Picatinny rail. The Girsan Witness 2311 Match X's rail is out of spec, causing fitment issues with lights like the Surefire X300.

What are the optic cut differences between the two pistols?

The Girsan Witness 2311 Match X uses an RMSC optic cut, which limits the available red dot sight options. The MAC9DS Comp features an RMR footprint, offering broader compatibility with popular optics.

What is the price range for these 2011-style pistols?

The Girsan Witness 2311 Match X retails for approximately $1,100, with some retailers offering it for around $1,050. The MAC9DS Comp is also positioned as a budget-friendly option in the 2011 market.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Roger Barrera (QVO Tactical)

View all →