Girsan Match X or MAC9DS Comp?

Published on July 29, 2025
Duration: 2:57

This review compares the Girsan Witness 2311 Match X and the MAC9DS Comp, both budget-friendly 2011-style 9mm pistols. While the Girsan offers a smooth action and flat shooting for around $1,100, its RMSC optic cut and out-of-spec Picatinny rail are significant drawbacks. The MAC9DS Comp, featuring an RMR footprint and a functional accessory rail, is favored by the reviewer despite similar trigger feel, making it a better value proposition.

Quick Summary

The MAC9DS Comp is recommended over the Girsan Match X due to its superior RMR optic footprint and in-spec accessory rail, which avoids fitment issues common with the Girsan's RMSC cut and out-of-spec rail. Both are budget 2011-style 9mm pistols with compensators.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Comparison Setup
  2. 00:29Girsan Match X Performance & Pricing
  3. 01:11Girsan Match X Drawbacks (Optic Cut, Rail)
  4. 01:41MAC9DS Comp Features (Optic Footprint, Magwell)
  5. 02:11Trigger Comparison & Final Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Girsan Match X and the MAC9DS Comp?

The Girsan Match X has an RMSC optic cut and an out-of-spec accessory rail, while the MAC9DS Comp features a more compatible RMR footprint and a functional rail. Both are 9mm, 2011-style pistols with compensators, but the MAC9DS is preferred for accessory mounting.

Which pistol is better for mounting optics and accessories, the Girsan Match X or MAC9DS Comp?

The MAC9DS Comp is better for mounting optics and accessories due to its RMR footprint optic cut and an in-spec Picatinny accessory rail. The Girsan Match X's RMSC cut limits optic choices, and its rail has fitment issues with common lights like the Surefire X300.

What is the approximate price range for the Girsan Match X and MAC9DS Comp?

The Girsan Witness 2311 Match X retails for approximately $1,100, with some retailers offering it for around $1,050. Pricing for the MAC9DS Comp is not explicitly stated but implied to be competitive within the budget 2011-style market.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Roger Barrera (QVO Tactical)

View all →