If I Could Only Have One: FN 509 MRD vs Walther PDP Compact

Published on October 15, 2023
Duration: 17:11

This video compares the FN 509 Midsize and the Walther PDP Compact, both equipped with aftermarket upgrades like red dot sights and compensators. The FN 509 features a Parker Mountain Machine comp, Holosun 507c Vulcan, and Apex Tactical trigger, offering versatile magazine options (15, 17, 24 rounds). The Walther PDP, also with a Holosun 507c Vulcan and Parker Mountain Machine comp, boasts superior out-of-the-box ergonomics and a lighter trigger pull (4-4.5 lbs vs. 5-5.5 lbs on the FN with Apex). While the PDP is preferred for competition due to its trigger, the FN 509 is considered slightly better for concealed carry due to its slimmer profile.

Quick Summary

The Walther PDP Compact is often preferred for competition due to its superior out-of-the-box trigger pull (4-4.5 lbs) and excellent ergonomics. The FN 509 Midsize, while capable, typically requires aftermarket trigger upgrades to match the PDP's performance and offers greater magazine versatility (15, 17, 24 rounds) and a slimmer profile for concealed carry.

Chapters

  1. 00:41Introduction
  2. 02:29FN 509 Midsize Overview
  3. 03:33FN 509 Upgrades (Comp, Red Dot, Trigger)
  4. 04:07FN 509 Magazine Options
  5. 05:19FN 509 Shooting Experience & Downsides
  6. 06:15FN 509 Apex Tactical Trigger Details
  7. 07:45Walther PDP Compact Overview
  8. 08:03Walther PDP Differences & Upgrades
  9. 08:51Walther PDP Magazine Compatibility
  10. 09:24Walther PDP Ergonomics & Grip
  11. 10:08Walther PDP Magazine Release
  12. 10:52Holosun 507c Vulcan Red Dot
  13. 11:16Walther PDP Shooting Experience
  14. 11:42Walther PDP Trigger vs. FN 509
  15. 13:18Which Pistol to Choose?
  16. 13:30Competition vs. Concealed Carry
  17. 14:33Final Comparison & Preference
  18. 15:05Unbiased Review Disclaimer
  19. 15:28Viewer Question & Call to Action
  20. 15:44Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the FN 509 Midsize and the Walther PDP Compact?

The Walther PDP Compact generally offers a superior out-of-the-box trigger pull and better ergonomics with its grip texture. The FN 509 Midsize provides more magazine capacity options and a slightly slimmer profile, making it potentially better for concealed carry. Both can be upgraded with red dots and compensators.

Which pistol is better for competition shooting, the FN 509 or the Walther PDP?

The Walther PDP Compact is recommended for competition shooting due to its excellent stock trigger, which is lighter and crisper than the FN 509's. While the FN 509 can be used, it often requires aftermarket trigger upgrades to match the PDP's performance out of the box.

How do the magazine capacities compare between the FN 509 Midsize and Walther PDP Compact?

The FN 509 Midsize offers more flexibility with magazine options, including 15-round flush-fit, 17-round, and larger 24-round magazines. The Walther PDP Compact typically uses 15-round magazines, though some compatibility with other models like the PPQ may exist.

Is the FN 509 or Walther PDP better for concealed carry?

The FN 509 Midsize is considered slightly better for concealed carry due to its slimmer profile compared to the Walther PDP Compact. While both are capable, the FN's reduced width can make it easier to conceal under clothing.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Fit'n Fire

View all →