Is 5.7x28mm Just Overpriced .22 Magnum? [Part 2]

Published on February 22, 2024
Duration: 11:51

This video compares the 5.7x28mm cartridge against the .22 Magnum, using ballistic gel tests to evaluate terminal performance. While 5.7x28mm offers lower recoil and better reliability than .22 Magnum, its terminal ballistics can be inconsistent across different loads and barrel lengths. .22 Magnum generally underperforms, especially in expansion, but some non-expanding loads show deep penetration from longer barrels.

Quick Summary

5.7x28mm offers better centerfire reliability and lower recoil than .22 Magnum, aiding shot placement. However, its terminal ballistics can be inconsistent across loads and barrel lengths. While more expensive, 5.7x28mm generally provides a slight edge in performance and reliability for self-defense applications.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: 5.7x28mm vs .22 Magnum
  2. 01:16Testing Standards: Gelatin & Barriers
  3. 02:20New 5.7x28mm Loads Tested
  4. 03:165.7x28mm Gel Test Results
  5. 06:27Comparing 5.7x28mm Velocity & Weight
  6. 07:17.22 Magnum Testing and Results
  7. 09:09Final Assessment: 5.7 vs .22 Mag

Frequently Asked Questions

How does 5.7x28mm compare to .22 Magnum in ballistic gel tests?

In ballistic gel tests, some 5.7x28mm loads showed better penetration and wounding than most .22 Magnum loads. However, certain .22 Magnum loads achieved deep penetration from longer barrels, while 5.7x28mm performance varied significantly with barrel length and specific ammunition type.

What are the advantages of 5.7x28mm over .22 Magnum for self-defense?

5.7x28mm offers centerfire reliability, which is generally more dependable than rimfire .22 Magnum. It also provides lower recoil, aiding shot placement, and typically performs better in semi-automatic firearms compared to .22 Magnum.

Did the tested 5.7x28mm loads meet self-defense penetration standards?

Performance varied. Some 5.7x28mm loads met or exceeded the 12-inch FBI minimum penetration standard in ballistic gel, while others, particularly from longer barrels, under-penetrated or over-expanded, failing to meet standards consistently.

Is 5.7x28mm considered overpriced compared to .22 Magnum?

While 5.7x28mm ammunition is significantly more expensive than .22 Magnum, its advantages in reliability and recoil management can justify the cost for some users. Terminal performance is comparable or slightly better depending on the specific loads tested.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Lucky Gunner Ammo

View all →