Is Glock 43X Better Than Sig P365XL For CCW

Published on August 30, 2024
Duration: 10:51

This video provides a detailed comparison between the Glock 43X and the Sig Sauer P365XL for concealed carry. The presenter, Ted from Line 45, offers an expert's perspective based on extensive shooting experience with various micro-compacts. Key differences in capacity, ergonomics, modularity, and shootability are highlighted, with specific insights into grip comfort for different hand sizes and the advantages of each platform's aftermarket support and factory features like sights and optic cuts.

Quick Summary

The Glock 43X and Sig Sauer P365XL are leading micro-compacts for concealed carry. The Glock 43X offers 10+1 capacity and a comfortable grip for larger hands, emphasizing simple, consistent shootability. The P365XL provides 12+1 capacity, superior modularity via its removable fire control unit, better factory sights, and an optic-ready slide, making it a more versatile platform.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Subcompact Leaders
  2. 00:11P365 vs Glock 43 Lineup
  3. 00:29Comparing P365XL and Glock 43X
  4. 00:48Channel Plug
  5. 00:58Presenter's Experience
  6. 01:06Visit to Lakewood Shooting Range
  7. 01:22Pre-Comparison Expectations
  8. 01:36Shooting Other Micro Compacts
  9. 01:52Glock 43X Specifications
  10. 02:19Sig P365XL Specifications
  11. 02:43Sight Radius Comparison
  12. 02:51Capacity Comparison
  13. 03:06Grip Real Estate
  14. 03:12Height Comparison
  15. 03:29Capacity vs. Size Explanation
  16. 03:46Glock 43X Architecture
  17. 04:06Sig Sauer Magazine Efficiency
  18. 04:09Modularity: P365 vs Glock
  19. 04:20Sig Sauer Removable Fire Control Unit
  20. 04:33What is a Fire Control Unit?
  21. 04:42P365 Customization Options
  22. 04:51Aftermarket Support Comparison
  23. 05:05Glock 43X Slide Swap Example
  24. 05:25Overall Modularity Conclusion
  25. 05:33Shootability: Glock 43X Favored
  26. 05:40Glock 43X Simplicity and Consistency
  27. 05:57Factory Trigger and Sights
  28. 06:04Sig P365XL Sights and Optic Cut
  29. 06:15Glock 43X MOS Version
  30. 06:32Glock 43X Modularity and Aftermarket
  31. 06:45Glock 43X Simplicity Appeal
  32. 06:53Glock 43X Grip Fit
  33. 07:07Grip Difference for Large Hands
  34. 07:10P365XL Pinky Finger Issue
  35. 07:13Importance of User-Friendly Grip
  36. 07:26Glock 43X Flush Fit Grip Comfort
  37. 07:38P365XL Shootability
  38. 07:45Expectations for P365XL
  39. 07:59Trigger Comparison Revisited
  40. 08:09Trigger Upgrade Recommendation
  41. 08:13Mcarbo Trigger
  42. 08:26Striker Fired Trigger Nuance
  43. 08:30Modularity vs. Aftermarket Support
  44. 08:32Glock 43X Aftermarket Speed
  45. 08:41Accuracy Comparison
  46. 08:58Pistol Accuracy vs. Shooter
  47. 09:08P365XL Advantage: Night Sights
  48. 09:17Glock 43X Polymer Sights
  49. 09:23Glock 43X Sight Replacement
  50. 09:27Reliability Comparison
  51. 09:37P365XL Reliability Observation
  52. 09:44P365XL Ergonomics
  53. 09:59Glock 43X Fast Shooting
  54. 10:04Concealed Carry Form Factor
  55. 10:11Glock 43X Size Advantage
  56. 10:14Extended Magazine Comparison
  57. 10:17Glock 43X Grip for Full Hand
  58. 10:21P365XL Superior Departments
  59. 10:29Conclusion
  60. 10:32Outro and Subscribe

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Glock 43X and Sig Sauer P365XL for concealed carry?

The Glock 43X offers a 10+1 capacity and a simpler, consistent shooting experience with a comfortable grip for larger hands. The P365XL boasts a higher 12+1 capacity, superior modularity via its removable fire control unit, better factory sights, and an optic cut. Both have similar overall lengths but differ in grip design and aftermarket support.

Which pistol, Glock 43X or Sig P365XL, is considered more modular?

The Sig Sauer P365XL is significantly more modular due to its removable fire control unit, which allows for easy swapping of slides, frames, and even calibers. While the Glock 43X has extensive aftermarket support and allows for slide swaps, it lacks the inherent modularity of the P365 platform.

How do the ergonomics and grip comfort compare between the Glock 43X and Sig P365XL?

For individuals with larger hands, the Glock 43X generally offers a more comfortable and full-handed grip with its flush-fit magazines. The P365XL's grip may result in the pinky finger hanging off for those with larger hands, though this can be remedied with extended magazines.

What are the advantages of the Sig P365XL's factory features over the Glock 43X?

The Sig P365XL comes standard with superior X-ray 3-day night sights and an optic-ready slide, which are significant advantages for aiming and red dot sight integration. The Glock 43X requires the MOS version for optics and its factory sights are considered less effective, often needing replacement.

Which pistol is better for concealed carry: Glock 43X or Sig P365XL?

The choice depends on priorities. The Glock 43X excels in simple shootability and grip comfort for larger hands, making it a reliable CCW. The P365XL offers higher capacity, greater modularity, and better factory features like sights and optic cuts, making it a more versatile option for those who value those aspects.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Line45

View all →