M&P 5.7 vs M&P .22 Mag — Same Frame, Different Rounds

Published on October 19, 2025
Duration: 17:57

This video provides a detailed comparison between the Smith & Wesson M&P 5.7 and the Smith & Wesson M&P 22 Magnum. The presenter highlights their identical frame design and explores differences in cost, recoil, and shooting experience. While acknowledging the 5.7's power and aesthetic appeal, the presenter ultimately favors the 22 Magnum for its cost-effectiveness and comparable shooting feel, making it a preferred choice for range practice and training.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson M&P 5.7 and M&P 22 Magnum share identical frames, making them visually similar. Key differences lie in their calibers: 5.7x28mm for the M&P 5.7 and 22 Magnum for the M&P 22 Magnum. While the 5.7 offers more power, the 22 Magnum is significantly more cost-effective for shooting, with comparable recoil, making it a preferred choice for practice.

Chapters

  1. 00:02Introduction & Range Day
  2. 00:21Introducing the M&P 5.7 and M&P 22 Magnum
  3. 00:30Visual Comparison: Identical Frames
  4. 01:02Thoughts on the 5.7 Round
  5. 01:57Cost-Effectiveness: 5.7 vs 22 Magnum
  6. 02:31Firearm Features: M&P 22 Magnum
  7. 03:55Firearm Features: M&P 5.7
  8. 04:38Side-by-Side Comparison: Differences
  9. 05:16External Safety Feature
  10. 05:24Identifying the Pistols
  11. 05:47Location: Range and Gun Club
  12. 06:03Magazine Capacity Discussion
  13. 06:21Shooting the M&P 22 Magnum
  14. 07:16Recoil of the 22 Magnum
  15. 07:21Shooting the M&P 5.7
  16. 07:58Recoil of the 5.7
  17. 08:03Recoil Comparison: No Difference Felt
  18. 08:12Are We Overpaying for the 5.7?
  19. 08:36Reloading for 22 Magnum
  20. 09:08M&P 22 Magnum Shooting Experience
  21. 09:225.7 Shooting Experience: Cost Factor
  22. 09:45Slide Drop Comparison
  23. 10:075.7 Shooting Experience: Cost Factor Continued
  24. 10:13Performance, Recoil, and Value
  25. 10:42Magazine Loading Experience
  26. 11:16Ammunition Used: FN & CCI
  27. 11:44Feel of the 22 Magnum
  28. 12:30Shooting the 5.7
  29. 13:01Feel of the 5.7
  30. 13:28Overall Impression: Love Both
  31. 13:35Choosing Between the Two
  32. 13:47Final Thoughts on 22 Magnum
  33. 14:26M&P 22 Magnum Recap
  34. 14:36M&P 5.7 Recap
  35. 15:04Speed of 5.7 Round
  36. 15:16Thread Protector Check
  37. 15:47Final Shooting Session
  38. 15:53Is 5.7 an Overpriced 22 Magnum?
  39. 16:095.7 as a Training Tool
  40. 16:59Recoil Comparison Revisited
  41. 17:20Viewer Feedback Request
  42. 17:25Presenter's Final Choice: 22 Magnum
  43. 17:43Thank You & Channel Support

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Smith & Wesson M&P 5.7 and M&P 22 Magnum?

The Smith & Wesson M&P 5.7 and M&P 22 Magnum share identical frames, making them look the same. Key differences include the 5.7 having a threaded barrel and being chambered in the more powerful 5.7x28mm round, while the 22 Magnum is chambered in 22 Magnum and is more cost-effective for shooting.

How does the recoil compare between the M&P 5.7 and M&P 22 Magnum?

According to the presenter, the recoil felt between the Smith & Wesson M&P 5.7 and the M&P 22 Magnum is nearly equal. No significant difference in recoil was perceived during shooting, making both pistols comfortable to handle.

Which pistol is more cost-effective for shooting, the M&P 5.7 or the M&P 22 Magnum?

The Smith & Wesson M&P 22 Magnum is significantly more cost-effective for shooting than the M&P 5.7. The 22 Magnum ammunition allows for a much higher volume of practice rounds without the high expense associated with the 5.7x28mm caliber.

What are the visual features of the Smith & Wesson M&P 22 Magnum and M&P 5.7?

Both pistols feature an optic-ready slide with blacked-out rear sights and an accessory rail. The M&P 22 Magnum has a green fluorescent front sight, while the M&P 5.7 has a white dot front sight. The M&P 5.7 also has ports in the slide and a threaded barrel.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Yoki Sturrup

View all →