M&P Shield vs Walther PPS M2

Published on July 13, 2016
Duration: 30:56

This video provides a detailed comparison between the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield and the Walther PPS M2, both popular 9mm single-stack pistols for concealed carry. The reviewer, Justin Opinion, offers insights from a shooting perspective, covering ergonomics, trigger feel, accuracy testing with various ammunition types, and one-handed shooting capabilities. He highlights key differences in magazine capacity and slide-to-frame fit, ultimately concluding that both are excellent choices with personal preference being the deciding factor, though he slightly favors the Shield for its higher capacity.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson M&P Shield and Walther PPS M2 are both excellent 9mm single-stack concealed carry pistols. Key differences include the Shield's higher magazine capacity (8 vs 7 rounds extended) and the PPS M2's superior slide-to-frame fit and slightly better trigger. Accuracy testing favored the PPS M2, while both perform well in one-handed shooting.

Chapters

  1. 00:36Introduction: M&P Shield vs Walther PPS M2
  2. 01:16Overview of Single Stack 9mm Carry Handguns
  3. 01:54Talon Grips Mention
  4. 02:17Shooting the M&P Shield
  5. 03:36Shooting the Walther PPS M2
  6. 04:08Walther PPS M2 Sight Picture & Ergonomics
  7. 04:51Trigger Comparison: Walther vs Shield
  8. 06:10Accuracy Testing Setup (10 Yards)
  9. 06:41M&P Shield Accuracy Results
  10. 10:47Walther PPS M2 Accuracy Results
  11. 13:42Accuracy Conclusion: PPS M2 More Accurate
  12. 13:59One-Handed Shooting: M&P Shield
  13. 15:52One-Handed Shooting: Walther PPS M2
  14. 17:07Guest Shooter's Opinion (Bri)
  15. 21:24Trigger Pull Weight Measurements
  16. 22:01Shooting Sig Sauer Ammo
  17. 24:24Overall Comparison & Recoil Perception
  18. 25:08Key Differences: Capacity & Fit
  19. 25:29Field Strip Comparison: PPS M2 vs Shield
  20. 27:35Slide-to-Frame Fit Comparison
  21. 28:49Reviewer's Overall Shooting Performance

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield and the Walther PPS M2?

The primary differences lie in magazine capacity, with the Shield holding one more round than the PPS M2 in both flush and extended configurations. The PPS M2 also features a superior slide-to-frame fit due to its rail design and is generally considered to have a slightly better trigger. Ergonomics and feel in hand are subjective and vary between users.

Which pistol is more accurate, the M&P Shield or the Walther PPS M2?

In the reviewer's accuracy testing at 10 yards, the Walther PPS M2 was notably more accurate than the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield. This was observed across various ammunition types, though individual results can vary based on the shooter and specific conditions.

How do the triggers compare on the M&P Shield and Walther PPS M2?

Walther is known for excellent striker-fired triggers, and the PPS M2's trigger was preferred by the reviewer over the M&P Shield's. The average trigger pull weight was measured at 6 lbs 2 oz for the PPS M2 and 6 lbs 11.5 oz for the Shield.

Is the M&P Shield or Walther PPS M2 better for one-handed shooting?

Both pistols are considered easy to shoot one-handed with manageable recoil and minimal muzzle flip. The M&P Shield offers slightly simpler recoil management and quicker sight recovery, while the PPS M2's grip tang can be a minor point of contact for some shooters.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Justin Opinion

View all →