Original SCAR 17 vs SCAR 17 Gen2 | Is It Worth the Upgrade?

Published on March 8, 2026
Duration: 19:57

This video provides a detailed comparison between the original FN SCAR 17 (Legacy) and the new SCAR 17 Gen 2. The hosts highlight key upgrades in the Gen 2, including a full MLOK rail system, improved bolt carrier group with scallop cuts for reduced mass, enhanced ambidextrous controls, and a new buffer system for significantly reduced recoil. While the Legacy model is still a capable rifle, the Gen 2 offers a more refined shooting experience and modern features, making it a worthwhile upgrade for many users.

Quick Summary

The FN SCAR 17 Gen 2 offers significant upgrades over the Legacy model, including a full MLOK rail, an improved bolt carrier group with reduced mass, and a hydraulic buffer for substantially less felt recoil. These enhancements lead to a smoother shooting experience and improved ergonomics, making it a compelling upgrade for many users.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the FN SCAR 17 Gen 2 and the Legacy SCAR 17?

The SCAR 17 Gen 2 features a full MLOK rail, an improved bolt carrier group with reduced mass, a hydraulic buffer for better recoil dampening, and enhanced ambidextrous controls. These upgrades contribute to a smoother shooting experience and improved ergonomics compared to the Legacy model.

Does the SCAR 17 Gen 2 have less recoil than the original SCAR 17?

Yes, the SCAR 17 Gen 2 significantly reduces felt recoil due to its updated bolt carrier group and the addition of a hydraulic buffer. This makes it more comfortable to shoot, especially during rapid fire, and reduces muzzle bounce.

Can you mount accessories easily on the SCAR 17 Gen 2?

Absolutely. The SCAR 17 Gen 2 comes equipped with a full MLOK rail system that extends further towards the barrel, providing ample space and a rigid platform for attaching various accessories like lights, grips, and bipods.

Are the controls on the SCAR 17 Gen 2 improved over the Legacy model?

Yes, the Gen 2 model features enhanced ambidextrous controls, including an enlarged bolt catch/release and a more accessible magazine release. These improvements enhance usability and speed for both right and left-handed shooters.

Is the SCAR 17 Gen 2 worth the upgrade from a Legacy SCAR 17?

For many users, the SCAR 17 Gen 2 is considered a worthwhile upgrade. The improved recoil impulse, enhanced ergonomics, and modern features like the MLOK rail offer a superior shooting experience and better adaptability for accessories.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from ClassicFirearms

View all →