Pump-Action vs Semi-Auto | This Shotgun CHANGED My MIND!

Published on February 19, 2020
Duration: 20:40

This video provides an in-depth comparison between a pump-action shotgun (Benelli SuperNova) and a semi-automatic shotgun (Remington Versa Max). The presenter, who typically favors pump-actions, is impressed by the Versa Max's significantly reduced recoil, reliability with various ammunition types, and faster cycling speed. The review highlights the Versa Max's gas operating system as a key factor in its performance, making it feel like a much lighter caliber shotgun and outperforming the pump-action in speed tests and a simulated course.

Quick Summary

The Remington Versa Max semi-automatic shotgun offers significantly reduced recoil and faster cycling compared to pump-action models like the Benelli SuperNova. Its advanced gas system reliably handles various ammunition types, making it feel like a lighter caliber shotgun and proving faster in timed drills and simulated courses.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Pump vs Semi-Auto Shotguns
  2. 00:36Introducing the Remington Versa Max
  3. 00:54Comparing with Benelli SuperNova Pump
  4. 01:17Versa Max Gas System Explained
  5. 01:30Recoil Claims of the Versa Max
  6. 02:16Loading the Versa Max with Bird Shot
  7. 02:51First Shots on Steel: Versa Max
  8. 03:41Rapid Fire with Versa Max
  9. 04:44Comparing Recoil with Benelli SuperNova
  10. 05:39Testing Buckshot in the Versa Max
  11. 06:30Ammunition Reliability Test Setup
  12. 07:02Cycling Different Ammunition Types
  13. 07:32Soda Can Test: Versa Max
  14. 08:20Shot Timer Speed Test: Pump vs Semi-Auto
  15. 09:06Benelli SuperNova Speed Test Results
  16. 09:26Remington Versa Max Speed Test Results
  17. 10:18Simulated Shooting Course Setup
  18. 13:45Benelli SuperNova Course Run
  19. 16:12Remington Versa Max Course Run
  20. 18:03Final Thoughts: Pump vs Semi-Auto
  21. 18:34Thanks to Turtle Lake Tactical
  22. 18:50Viewer Opinions and Conclusion
  23. 20:06Bee Swarm After Shooting

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between pump-action and semi-automatic shotguns?

Pump-action shotguns require manual cycling of the bolt for each shot, offering simplicity and reliability with various loads. Semi-automatic shotguns use gas or recoil to cycle the action automatically, providing faster follow-up shots and generally lower perceived recoil, though they can be more sensitive to ammunition type.

How does the Remington Versa Max compare in recoil to other shotguns?

The Remington Versa Max is lauded for its exceptionally low recoil, with the presenter stating it feels like shooting a 20-gauge or even less, comparable to an AK-47. This is attributed to its advanced gas operating system, making it one of the softest-shooting 12-gauge shotguns available.

Is the Remington Versa Max reliable with different types of ammunition?

Yes, the Remington Versa Max is designed with a gas operating system that adjusts for different ammunition pressures. It demonstrated reliability in cycling a variety of loads, including bird shot, buck shot, and even heavy 3-inch magnum rounds, without issues.

Which shotgun is faster for shooting: pump-action or semi-automatic?

Semi-automatic shotguns are generally faster for shooting than pump-action models. In a timed drill, the Remington Versa Max completed four shots in just over one second, while the Benelli SuperNova pump-action took over two seconds, showcasing the semi-auto's advantage in cycling speed.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from 1ShotTV

View all →